Ouch. Still, hard to find fault with the analysis, no matter how unpopular it may be with much of the readership of HN. Many folks here would love to sell a company to Yahoo! for $30MM after 18mo with minimal engineering effort and download numbers probably below those of many folks reading the news on HN.
We should all be very happy. This is a sign that easy money is still out there for the clever individual. I applaud the kid for what he has done. Yahoo might be stupid, but we've known that for a long long time.
What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
31–40 of 288 posts
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#32> By definition, Yahoo's directors know how to spend Yahoo's cash reserves best. This is absolutely incorrect. There are many instances in which there is a personal financial connection between a board member and an acquired company. For example, a board member is a limited in a VC fund. Didn't bother reading after that.
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#33What's actually right about Yahoo's purchase of Summly: we are still talking about it, and are still reminded that Yahoo exists. The marketing was great (the video is really well-done), and to be honest yahoo really could use some marketing boost at a time like this.
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#34Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#35I think the author makes this comment: "Summly's entire business model seems to revolve around catering to this demographic. Frankly, it pains me." I reads like a critique of Chubby Checker's "Twist" from a professor a Julliard. Perhaps, and I say that because I can't know what they were really thinking, but perhaps that was the point. This company had successfully "catered to this demographic" (which was defined as…
> people who could quickly assemble a MVP from existing APIs that appealed to the emerging cohort of buyers and trendsetters. Oh man reading that I just realized that was exactly describing the type of consulting gigs I always get (and I'm young). Are we a side effect of the pump-and-dump VC culture or is this a legitimate new way of developing software/products?
However, I feel like people aren't very upfront with the fact that they are building on top of APIs. For whatever reason, there's this perception that arranging existing resources into a more valuable arrangement is somehow not a valid approach.
I'd love to hear others thoughts on this.
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#36This is my (pessimistic) take on this Summly thing. I think the following scenario happened: 15 year old kid does something with computers and for some reason the press is all over it. Some smart investors thinks; "hey, I can use this to make money". They invest money into this 15 year old which gives him more press coverage. Wait a few years and the investor gets his buddies at Yahoo to buy it for a substantial amou…
The first investor was Horizons Ventures, the investment arm of Hong Kong billionaire Li Ka-Shing, who put in $300k.
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#37EDIT they could be buying market-product fit...? but yes, if they killed it... hmmm...
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#38Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#39From his own quoted post: "I lived through 8 years of a non-reading president along with everyone else. I know that the brogrammers out there are constantly getting texts from their buddies to plan the weekend's broactivities..." Thanks Professor, now I don't have to continue reading your post – ie, you're kind of a jerk.
Do you know which president I had in mind? I lived through quite a few 8 year terms, and yes, that includes Reagan. If your response is "but everyone knows which president you were referring to," then surely it's fair game to refer to whoever that is since the facts are universally accepted? :-)
I think there's a new qualification for TL;DR - DFIAT - didn't fit in a tweet.
Re: What's Actually Wrong with Yahoo's Purchase of Summly
#40[0]: http://blogs.wsj.com/tech-europe/2013/03/26/what-does-30-mil...