Live data from Hacker News

Critical Thinking: Why Is It So Hard to Teach? [pdf]

aft.org

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Critical Thinking: Why Is It So Hard to Teach? [pdf]

#31
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Government school" is a wonderful example of how snappy terminology short circuits critical thinking. It may be rewarding on some level to assume that every school operated by the government is part of a monolithic agenda to turn the nation's youth into unquestioning robots to staff our various production lines. That is simply not true.

That is simply not true. Please elaborate.

I suppose the most compelling reason to disbelieve the sheeple agenda theory is Occam's Razor. Do not attribute malice where incompetence is an adequate explanation. If our high schoolers are generally lacking in critical thinking skills, is it necessarily because millions of bureaucrats occupying several layers of hierarchy are all in lockstep in actively, intentionally making it so? Or is it possible--and more likely--that critical thinking is difficult to do in the first place, and even harder to teach, and anyone who is any good at it in the first place is far more likely to be employable in a setting that is favorable to that of the public schools?

I'm not slagging on public schools and teachers! Well, OK, yeah, I suppose I am, at least a little. I know a fair number of teachers. Some of them really like working with kids at that developmental stage, and some of them are really good at motivating their students to achieve. Others don't like the kids, and have become very good at identifying the minimum amount of effort they need to put forth to stay employed. Kind of like almost any other random cluster of professionals.

Re: Critical Thinking: Why Is It So Hard to Teach? [pdf]

#32
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is simply not true. Please elaborate.

I suppose the most compelling reason to disbelieve the sheeple agenda theory is Occam's Razor. Do not attribute malice where incompetence is an adequate explanation. If our high schoolers are generally lacking in critical thinking skills, is it necessarily because millions of bureaucrats occupying several layers of hierarchy are all in lockstep in actively, intentionally making it so? Or is it possible--and more like…

Who are these teachers training their students for? I prefer looking at numbers, and the numbers don't look too fair for employees:

http://occupygeorge.com/

Post reply on HN