Live data from Hacker News

Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

telegraphindia.com

31–40 of 75 posts

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#31
What we should look for in the article is simply "the virtue of will power." At least thats what i will. Does anyone really have the time to doubt and investigate the bullshit doubts. She may be a schemer, i don't care, but her determination and conviction is what attracts me and that's what i or anybody else should take away from this article.

And i gotta say hailing from Calcutta (now Kolkata) and becoming what she is now, really Really take balls of titanium.

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#32

She was lonesome, without a child and I became her daughter who she started raising instead of me helping her. She gave me $30,000 one day and said: “I want you to go to Harvard.” Wow, that is some luck!

All business success stories have some element of luck (most of them a great deal). It's just a question of how much and what you did with it.

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#33
post #12

This story is very sketchy. Couple of Google searches do not turn up anything useful about her beyond the standard PRish articles. https://www.google.com/search?q=chanda+zaveri+linus+pauling https://www.google.com/search?q=chanda+zaveri+uc+santa+barba... I tried looking list of people who have received honorary doctorate degrees from Harvard but couldn't find the entire list. But it is not in the summary list they ha…

A few more links http://www.fairandhandsome.ae/faq

check the #3 item on FAQ. Imami does credit her for the formula of fair and handsome (which is a fairly big company in India and a famous product).

Some more details of her company

http://www.walkersresearch.com/Profilepages/A/Activor_Corp.a...

no website though http://www.activorcorporation.net/

Not sure if she's fake or true

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#34
post #9
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except for most musicians, actors, actors turned prostitutes, lawyers who are waiters, near-homeless programmers who read HN, startup employees who got screwed by finance people, etc. ;) I'm just saying there might be other factors: like the industry you work in, your interests, govt subsidization of your industry, saturation/supply/demand, etc. Someone interested in makeup is going to have a different life than some…

> near-homeless programmers who read HN You have to screw up pretty hard to be near-homeless as a programmer in this environment.

It's very easy to become homeless when you get the 1-2 punches of illness and divorce. A friend of mine went from riches to rags within a year that way.

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#35

A shiny example of a country filled with incompetent people, including the ones who frequent HN. How can a journalist be such a fool to publish something as ridiculous as this? A simple Google search can confirm that she is fake. With this article behind her back, don't be surprised if she ends up on a '50 under 50' list within a year.

Wow! By this metric if you can't find my life's story on Google, I must be fake. And, pari passu, anything you find about me on Google must be not fake. Unless, of course, your post was an attempt at trolling... In which case, I must admit, you've succeeded. ;-)

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was searching for a better word. I thought of pioneering but it was too tame, swashbuckling but it was too far out. Can you suggest something better? I mean they are go-getters and bending the boundaries of the system.

Is this actually statistically true? Wikipedia says it's the third largest metro region in India. Apart from outliers providing anecdotes, what's the reason to say people from this particular city are exceptional pioneers and "bend the boundaries"?

West Bengal in general is characterized by such people and Calcutta is like the center of West Bengal like Paris and France. They tend to be much more into the arts and culture. Bengali, the local language is very sweet. If you hear it it sounds like they are singing. e.g. Rabindranath Tagore.

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#37

I was more surprised when I found out that Freddie Mercury (vocalist for Queen) spent much of his childhood between Africa & India [1], moving to the UK only after the age of 17 under trying circumstances. ~B [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freddie_Mercury

Of course. His real name is Farokh Balsara.

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#39
post #38

A true Slumdog millionaire. A shining example of Luck, opportunity and will playing their part. Truth is indeed stranger than fiction.

A true Slumdog millionaire. Not quiet the same, as she comes from a wealthy family. She was running away from the social pressure of getting married and ended up with what followed. [NB: Nothing to take away from what she achieved, I am just responding to the term Slumdog Millionaire used in this context]

Re: Calcutta girl who fled home & marriage at 17 returns as millionaire US innovator

#40
post #7

That is why they call America the Land of Opportunity. If you work hard enough, you dreams will come true here.

The opportunity is the same in most Western countries. Nothing special about America in this respect.

I think it's easier to go from nothing to absurdly successful in the US than almost anywhere else. It's probably harder to go from nothing to the middle class in the US than it is in Europe or other developed countries. It's also getting harder to remain in the middle class in the US than in e.g. Germany. It may be easier to go from middle class to 300-500k/yr in the US than in most other places, too (still difficult, but easier here).

The big area where the US is failing people is at the low end. Multi-generational poverty, as well as people who had 1-2 generations of moderate success dropping back to poverty.

Post reply on HN