Live data from Hacker News

BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

thenextweb.com

31–38 of 38 posts

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#32
post #3

How do you think it compares to Crashplan multi backup feature http://support.crashplan.com/doku.php/feature/multi_destinat... ?

As a Crashplan user, I see it as only slightly related. Crashplan is a backup solution, with multiple versions available for restoration. These are stored in a compressed and optionally encrypted blob of folders and files with restoration controlled by Crashplan's GUI.

BitTorrent's Sync application appears to be a way to keep the current version of files syncronized on multiple computers without a cloud (server) intermediary and without a history of previous versions.

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#33
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use git-annex assistant for that. When a new file appears in a certain directory in my VPS, the Assistant will automatically sync it to my Desktop machine (which has a 2TB disk). When the VPS disk space gets low, a script will run "git annex drop --in=here --in=desktop", which deletes files that have already been copied to the Desktop (but not without first checking if they're there). Then, on my laptop, I can just…

Does it work on windows yet?

Not yet. See: http://git-annex.branchable.com/todo/windows_support/

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#34
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use git-annex assistant for that. When a new file appears in a certain directory in my VPS, the Assistant will automatically sync it to my Desktop machine (which has a 2TB disk). When the VPS disk space gets low, a script will run "git annex drop --in=here --in=desktop", which deletes files that have already been copied to the Desktop (but not without first checking if they're there). Then, on my laptop, I can just…

Does it work on windows yet?

Not according to the website:

http://git-annex.branchable.com/todo/windows_support/

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#35
post #15

And where are the files stored? If I create a 'Sync'ed file, switch off the computer and start the laptop, the file needs to be stored somewhere. And if this somewhere is the torrent swarm, then I would expect an interesting discussion on cryptography and (perhaps) fountain codes etc. ( Unfortunately the blog post [1] is even less detailed than OP's submission.) [1] http://blog.bittorrent.com/2013/01/24/test-bittorre…

Maybe on a Rhaspberry Pi you keep running somewhere?

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#36
post #2

I guess a big difference is that your data isn't stored at a 3rd party somewhere. That's one of the things that are good about Dropbox - if you delete your stuff, you can go back and fetch it.

It is also one of the things that are bad about Dropbox: even if you delete your files, someone else still has a copy. Worse, it's almost never encrypted client-side. That is often not an issue of course, Dropbox is great.

Dropbox has its demons, however, and it's probably not something you should rely on for its security.

I used to use it as a means of keeping an encrypted file synced across machines, but when you re-lock up the file it... well, encrypts it, which means re-arranging ALL the bits, so a diff (how dropbox syncs) is just the whole damn file.

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#37
I have been using AeroFS ( https://www.aerofs.com/ ) for a couple months now and it works similarly.

The files sync between all your AeroFS computers (and supports selecting syncing too) instead of to a single server so I basically have literally 100s of GBs of 'cloud'/Dropbox-like storage available. And as a bonus, its completely free for all this 'unlimited' storage.

Re: BitTorrent reveals Sync, a new file synchronization tool

#38

This is what I've been waiting for. A dropbox-like service that uses BitTorrent. Seriously, with the way BitTorrent is integrated into all kinds of services and devices, it would be like instant Dropbox integration, with everything. You could start using the cool Torrent scheduling stuff to, for example, automatically transfer large files to a partner, quickly, as they're produced on the other end. Or to your TV, wha…

I use git-annex assistant for that. When a new file appears in a certain directory in my VPS, the Assistant will automatically sync it to my Desktop machine (which has a 2TB disk). When the VPS disk space gets low, a script will run "git annex drop --in=here --in=desktop", which deletes files that have already been copied to the Desktop (but not without first checking if they're there). Then, on my laptop, I can just…

Seconding git-annex.

I haven't used git-annex assistant, but git-annex alone has revolutionized the way that I think about and interact with my filesystem(s).

Post reply on HN