Live data from Hacker News

FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

tomshardware.com

31–40 of 126 posts

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#31

We're quickly reaching the point where Lidar isn't needed, pure vision workflows are getting much better.

LiDAR in drones is not necessarily the "stereo vision" application you are thinking of, it can also be something as simple as a LiDAR altimeter.

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Steel manning this argument: Electronic warfare resistant loitering munitions. They would transmit sparse point clouds to the enemy for training. Not saying I support it.

How is this worse than 4k video, in this age of analytical abundance? The steel content of this argument is pretty low; it's essentially 'technology operates normally = national security risk.' Why not ban pencils? You can draw maps or schematics of secret things, plus they can be used to stab people!

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/U1MigIJXJx8

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#35

Another move to remove competition for Don Jr.?

That, or to avoid surrendering yet another technology relevant to the future to China. As if them manufacturing the bulk of world's solar panels, wind turbines and heading for EVs isn't bad enough.

Stopping US import of any of these technologies doesn't suddenly make them disappear. They still exist. You can't "ignore them and they'll go away", this is real life.

And as an American citizen I am always hearing how bad it is for China to have a leg up on us in X, Y or Z, and yet our government is the one that is regularly saber rattling (and starting wars over!) the shifting economic realities of the US clearly being an empire in decline.

These days we also regularly saber rattle our own "allies" for fuck's sake.

Long past time to ask yourself if maybe we're the baddies.

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#37
Aaaaand this "ban" will be just as incompetently executed as the ban that happened like, what, a couple weeks ago about drones? Literally all the manufacturers did was create some shell companies, change the branding a bit, and boom. So much for banning things, amiright? Not to mention the shear amount of customer confusion because now they have to figure out what differentiates all these new brands nobody has ever heard of.

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#39
FCC's move is fair .. an adjacent view to this is best summed up by Palmer Lucky in this interview (https://www.hoover.org/research/palmer-luckey-wants-america-...?) ...

“Imagine if there had been a novel … like a Tom Clancy novel” where, during the Cold War, the Pentagon’s most secure electronics would be made by the Soviet Union under Kremlin supervision ..

Imagine running an aerial LiDAR/SLAM over gov sites .. mil bases .. ports .. airports .. power plants ... eeven if the system is completely benign .. ur talking about a technology whose output can be an extremely detailed representation of the physical environmen.

Re: FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US

#40
post #37

Aaaaand this "ban" will be just as incompetently executed as the ban that happened like, what, a couple weeks ago about drones? Literally all the manufacturers did was create some shell companies, change the branding a bit, and boom. So much for banning things, amiright? Not to mention the shear amount of customer confusion because now they have to figure out what differentiates all these new brands nobody has ever h…

When the entire system is created with loopholes for the rich, this is what happens. lawlessness, disguised as lawfullness.
Post reply on HN