Live data from Hacker News

Why I am not going to buy a computer

karlvmuller.com

31–40 of 103 posts

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#31
post #23
post #12

I like buying old flagships since I couldn't afford them like 5-10 years ago. Still a few on my list would be neat to try like Specter 360, eventually I want one of the current newest XPS-13s I recently got a Pixelbook for $80 running Ubuntu on that, great little device as far as thinness Also like buying/trying out weird computers or old, like the ASUS Eee PCs or Librettos

did you even read the blog post my guy

Skimmed "write by hand or typewriter" yeah I'm not like that, I am rote based though so have to type into a computer to remember notes

Who wants to f around with a typewriter anyway I guess this guy in particular does

How you gonna blog with a typewriter

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#32
post #3

The uncanny valley is happening with enterprise work. My boss is in love with Copilot writing documentation that we've sorely needed for many years. He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before. We do this and then no one reads it. I've asked people about it and they seem disillusioned. It wasn't written by a human so they see no human value in it. They view it as AI writing documen…

[dead]

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#33
post #3

The uncanny valley is happening with enterprise work. My boss is in love with Copilot writing documentation that we've sorely needed for many years. He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before. We do this and then no one reads it. I've asked people about it and they seem disillusioned. It wasn't written by a human so they see no human value in it. They view it as AI writing documen…

AI or not, most people never cared about documentation. I have always had to fight tooth and nail to get people to write shit down, and that hasn't changed with AI. In 2021 I wrote a ton of docs for outlining our deployment and various how-tos, basically just got a "cool thanks bro" for my time. People never cared, I think AI is just a convenient modern excuse.

Work for a big enough enterprise and you’ll spend tons of time making reams of documentation that nobody ever reads and only exists to check a box. Stick around long enough and maybe a 3rd party auditor will read some of it.

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#35
post #11
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before Here's the problem I have. No doubt an LLM made it faster to write those docs, but did you fully spot check it for accuracy? A lot of people aren't which I think is why the average joe hates it. These docs can still have AI generated mistakes which are easily glossed over by a regular human.

> Here's the problem I have. No doubt an LLM made it faster to write those docs, but did you fully spot check it for accuracy? Yes. That was just the writing portion, there is a whole team that works on publishing and proof reading and there are acceptance levels all the way up to the CISO where people validate they read it and approved of the contents. Even with that, no one cares about it.

I assume by "proof-reading" you don't mean just checking that the text doesn't contain spelling mistakes or is incoherent, but including that the content is actually correct. If your people actually invest that much into documentation, what the point of the LLM? Isn't the actual writing part like 10% of the total effort expended, in terms of man-hours?

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#36

> AI is probabilistic and any probabilistic system can inherently never be perfect as it also still makes numerous mistakes. Work still needs to be reviewed by humans. I don't know why people keep saying this. I don't believe code needs to be reviewed by humans. Are humans infallible? I think 80%+ of code is basically human slop. Do we review the assembly language that is generated by compilers? I think given where A…

[deleted]

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#37
post #3

The uncanny valley is happening with enterprise work. My boss is in love with Copilot writing documentation that we've sorely needed for many years. He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before. We do this and then no one reads it. I've asked people about it and they seem disillusioned. It wasn't written by a human so they see no human value in it. They view it as AI writing documen…

> no one reads it. [... ] they seem disillusioned Regardless of reasons they tell you, if no one reads your documentation, then it isn't good enough. Good documentation gets read, as long as it is good. It sounds to me like you're disillusioned, if you're not responding to the feedback, even if you sometimes have to look through the reasons people tell you on the surface.

There are many reasons people might not read your documentation, and "it isn't good enough" is only one of them. To wit:

   - they don't know about it
   - they can't find it when they need it
   - they just don't read documentation (quite common)
   - they've been burned by stale docs in the past
and I'm sure other reasons besides.

And while you're right, that sometimes/usually/always the documentation isn't good enough, it's a fallacy to think that the person who has the information needed, has the skill to write docs that are good enough for people to read. And if they have the skill, they don't have the time to apply it sufficiently.

Let's face it: good docs aren't valued. Not by the organization structurally, and not by the individuals within the organization. You may say that you value it, but I bet that if someone offered to document whatever code or process to your 'good enough' level, and it would take a month to do, as a manager you would tell them to take less time (i.e. create bad documentation) and get to something more important.

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#38
post #8
post #3

The uncanny valley is happening with enterprise work. My boss is in love with Copilot writing documentation that we've sorely needed for many years. He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before. We do this and then no one reads it. I've asked people about it and they seem disillusioned. It wasn't written by a human so they see no human value in it. They view it as AI writing documen…

> He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before Here's the problem I have. No doubt an LLM made it faster to write those docs, but did you fully spot check it for accuracy? A lot of people aren't which I think is why the average joe hates it. These docs can still have AI generated mistakes which are easily glossed over by a regular human.

Ignoring how a thing was created, is it useful to me (or anyone)?

The fascination with LLM coding seems rooted in the new ability to create something with very little effort. Unfortunately, some people do not see the trade comes at the moment you have to evaluate the output for fitness or quality.

It turns out that you often need to understand the thing pretty well in order to be qualified to determine the quality of the output. That tends to dilute time gains, unless you leave off the evaluation step.

Re: Why I am not going to buy a computer

#39
post #3

The uncanny valley is happening with enterprise work. My boss is in love with Copilot writing documentation that we've sorely needed for many years. He and I can bang out tons of it in minutes that would have taken months before. We do this and then no one reads it. I've asked people about it and they seem disillusioned. It wasn't written by a human so they see no human value in it. They view it as AI writing documen…

> We do this and then no one reads it.

A) this is what happens with documentation, in general.

B) as an experienced reader of documentation, I can often tell when the documentation is likely to be accurate. It's not worth reading documentation that's inaccurate. AI written things tend to be inaccurate and not worth reading.

You should be happy that your people know to ignore the work you and the boss half assed.

Post reply on HN