Live data from Hacker News

Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

ns.nl

31–40 of 151 posts

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#32

Nice pass. Would be perfect for my wife and I since we don't commute for work. There is something similar here in Switzerland but not as good. Funny fact: there are cities here that have tried to make public transport free. But the constitution says public transport must have a "reasonable charge". It's obvious that law was created to not overcharge but the courts have ruled that it also means that there can't be no…

Personally, I find no charge very, very reasonable lol

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#33

Nice pass. Would be perfect for my wife and I since we don't commute for work. There is something similar here in Switzerland but not as good. Funny fact: there are cities here that have tried to make public transport free. But the constitution says public transport must have a "reasonable charge". It's obvious that law was created to not overcharge but the courts have ruled that it also means that there can't be no…

My understanding of that ruling is that, the intent of the constitutional clause is not only to prevent ticket prices from being raised unfairly, but also to prevent ticket prices from being so low that they no longer cover the cost of running the network, which would shift that cost to the general taxpayer. Still frustrating (if the taxpayers want it, might as well let them have it), but not purely a semantic techni…

Public transport is not sustainable from ticket prices alone anywhere in Europe.

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#34
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who use it more really should contribute something vs those who never use it.

Should people who use roads more contribute something vs those who don't?

Yes. This was the original intent behind the gasoline tax.

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#35
post #17

Nice pass. Would be perfect for my wife and I since we don't commute for work. There is something similar here in Switzerland but not as good. Funny fact: there are cities here that have tried to make public transport free. But the constitution says public transport must have a "reasonable charge". It's obvious that law was created to not overcharge but the courts have ruled that it also means that there can't be no…

That sort of begs the question about elevators and escalators. I’ve never been charged riding those, and I can’t imagine fares tacked on in Switzerland. Have they been ruled on? An elevator in a public building is very much public transport. I know it’s stupid, but I’m genuinely curious now.

[deleted]

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#36
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who use it more really should contribute something vs those who never use it.

Should people who use roads more contribute something vs those who don't?

Yes and they do in many jurisdictations. In Austria gas tax is used for road maintenance, on top of that there are tolls for highways.

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#37

Nice pass. Would be perfect for my wife and I since we don't commute for work. There is something similar here in Switzerland but not as good. Funny fact: there are cities here that have tried to make public transport free. But the constitution says public transport must have a "reasonable charge". It's obvious that law was created to not overcharge but the courts have ruled that it also means that there can't be no…

Free public transport routes worldwide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_free_public_transport_...

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#38
post #29
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For sure. I currently live in the US (fairly rural) and I would kill to have my transportation-related costs reduced to about $150/mo. But where I live, I simply need to have a car to do any basic thing since the moment I step off my driveway, there aren’t even footpaths.

I live in the Netherlands and have absolutely no need for this ticket. When I need to go somewhere, I just walk or bike there, never takes more than 20 minutes. I cannot even imagine living in American suburbia

I moved here from The Netherlands in 2004, and have now lived in Florida, California, and Mississippi and stayed for prolonged periods in many US cities for my job. I wouldn’t feel safe riding a bicycle anywhere here considering the speed of traffic, the size of the vehicles, and lack of dedicated biking infrastructure. It’s a completely different world when you share the road with angry F150 drivers blasting past you at 80 MPH. No, thank you.

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#39

What I don't understand about initiatives like this is... why bother charging at all? wouldn't the system be more efficient without a fare process? at that point you don't have to maintain an entire money handling system.

[dead]

Re: Dutch Railways offers unlimited off-peak train travel nationwide for €49/month

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My understanding of that ruling is that, the intent of the constitutional clause is not only to prevent ticket prices from being raised unfairly, but also to prevent ticket prices from being so low that they no longer cover the cost of running the network, which would shift that cost to the general taxpayer. Still frustrating (if the taxpayers want it, might as well let them have it), but not purely a semantic techni…

Public transport is not sustainable from ticket prices alone anywhere in Europe.

True for local lines of everyday transportation. But actually high speed trains are sustainable, at least in France.

But also they are super expensive.

Post reply on HN