Live data from Hacker News

ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

phoronix.com

31–40 of 83 posts

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Isn't it funny how such incidents on Linux are rare enough that they make headlines, but on Windows that's been the baseline expected state of things for so long that nobody bats an eye anymore. Btw if you're running an OS that's never had a malware incident, please, tell us!

Conversely, this kind of attack: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XZ_Utils_backdoor

...is essentially impossible to pull off against commercial operating systems, because their core components are all written in-house by staff with photo ID badges, details with HR, tax returns filed with the government, and a cubicle that makes sure that they're locals and not some faceless anonymous hacker identifiable by nothing other than a throwaway faked email address!

I get that there was a lot of "stigma" about open source, the world largely forgot about it, but... actually, in this sense of allowing anonymous contributions it remains a very real risk.

"Jia Tan" was almost certainly a paid professional hacker working for a nation-state actor. Their "helpful contributions" to XZ utils was nowhere near a full-time effort. They certainly had "other irons on the fire", most probably in the Linux kernel or immediately adjacent to it.

He's probably not the only one doing this kind of "work".

For all you know, Linux has more remote exploits purposefully baked into it than Windows has security bugs inadvertently left in it... and don't forget Linux has bugs leading to security vulnerabilities too!

A rough count of "named" CVE 10.0 score (or close to it) vulns in the last 5 years:

7 for Microsoft: ProxyLogon, ProxyShell, ProxyNotShell, LDAPNightmare, PrintNightmare, noPac, Follina

10 for Linux: XZ Utils, regreSSHion, Leaky Vessels, Copy Fail, PwnKit, Dirty Pipe, Looney Tunables, GameOver(lay), Baron Samedit, Sequoia

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't it funny how such incidents on Linux are rare enough that they make headlines, but on Windows that's been the baseline expected state of things for so long that nobody bats an eye anymore. Btw if you're running an OS that's never had a malware incident, please, tell us!

Windows stopped having serious malware problems at least 10 years ago the ransomware campaigns would have happened on any OS enterprises use, because they were not security flaws in the OS

ClickFix which used Windows Update, and LNK that used Microsoft's signing keys, would disagree. There are still large and ongoing attacks that exploit Windows, and they are a serious problem - its just the attackers are less pointed at the everyday person, and more at corps and govs.

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't it funny how such incidents on Linux are rare enough that they make headlines, but on Windows that's been the baseline expected state of things for so long that nobody bats an eye anymore. Btw if you're running an OS that's never had a malware incident, please, tell us!

Conversely, this kind of attack: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XZ_Utils_backdoor ...is essentially impossible to pull off against commercial operating systems, because their core components are all written in-house by staff with photo ID badges, details with HR, tax returns filed with the government, and a cubicle that makes sure that they're locals and not some faceless anonymous hacker identifiable by nothing other…

Windows has had a lot more named high-CVEs than that: MonikerLink, QueueJumper, Certifried, HiveNightmare...

As for "Linux", you'd need to specify the distro and environment, because Linux systems can be very different from one another. Your XZ example for instance didn't even affect most enterprise distros (like RHEL). regreSSHion didn't affect any musl libc distros like Alpine, but other systems would've also been unaffected had you set your LoginGraceTime to 0, which any sysadmin worth their salt would've done so. Leaky Vessels fails on SELinux enforcing distros (RHEL, Fedora etc) and sandboxed environments. I could go on, but you get the picture. Comparing the number of "Linux" vulnerabilities to Windows is completely pointless.

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#35

Given enough time, open-source will win. Just think about how more and more people are programming and how that will draw them to open-source.

> development for 28 years now

> given enough time

This has been a lifetime for a slice of the human population.

It’s getting into Sagrada Familia territory.

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#36

What is the benefit compared to a compatibility layer? Is it easier for future maintenance? It's definitely a huge improvement towards "FOSS Windows."

You can run proprietary drivers with ReactOS since it replicates the driver layer too.

So unlike Linux systems with Nvidia Kepler cards, you can still run the most up-to-date desktop environment. Or if you have an obscure WiFi card, you can use the Windows drivers.

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#38
post #35

Given enough time, open-source will win. Just think about how more and more people are programming and how that will draw them to open-source.

> development for 28 years now > given enough time This has been a lifetime for a slice of the human population. It’s getting into Sagrada Familia territory.

See, at this rate it won’t even take a century!

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#39

Given enough time, open-source will win. Just think about how more and more people are programming and how that will draw them to open-source.

Only if it keeps being relevant for the computing model.

Case in point, ReactOS is far behind what Windows 11 is capable of, and this not taking into account the ARM and CoPilot+ PC hardware changes in modern motherboards.

It is nonetheless relevant, especially in the presence of escape mechanisms to oppressive governments, and digital sovereignty.

Re: ReactOS (FOSS "Windows") achieves 3D-accelerated Half-Life on real hardware

#40
post #35

Given enough time, open-source will win. Just think about how more and more people are programming and how that will draw them to open-source.

> development for 28 years now > given enough time This has been a lifetime for a slice of the human population. It’s getting into Sagrada Familia territory.

This is an absolute tangent (a perpendicular one if you will), but I thought the Sagrada Familia is completed: https://www.forbes.com/sites/ceciliarodriguez/2026/06/10/bar...

The article talks about construction on the exterior, the cross on the main tower, the Pope's visit and commemoration of the architect, etc. while on the official website the timeline says "Today, more than 140 years after the laying of the cornerstone, construction continues on the Basilica": https://sagradafamilia.org/en/history-of-the-temple

So which one is it? Is this one of those cases where we have to define "done" first?

Post reply on HN