Live data from Hacker News

Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

noslopgrenade.com

31–40 of 453 posts

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#31

Replace "Them" with "Coworker" and the point of linking to the site is instantly understood (a LMGTFY-style shaming with a dash of humor to soften the blow) With "Them" I wasn't sure if you meant the AI companies, some dude I didn't recognize in the avatar, scammers, coworkers, etc...

LMGTFY definitely did not soften the blow, maybe it even increased the shaming factor lmao

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#32
post #12

I swear most executives can barely read so you're not doing your career any favors sending them more than 150 characters.

The CEO of one firm I worked at wrote emails totally in bullet point format.

Made it much easier to read and you could just reply with:

> bullet point

response

which made life much easier

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#33
post #5

> Should we use Redis or Memcached? Couldn't they have used an example aimed at a broader audience? I'm in IT but even I barely know what Redis or Memcached is about (never used either).

90% of people here know what those are.

And with a more broadly applicable example we could share the link with friends, family and coworkers who aren't on HN.

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#35
post #17

This is slop too though, right? > Pasting a massive AI-generated response into a chat or email where a human would write one sentence. It destroys the medium itself. Nobody writes essays in Slack. It's only possible because of AI copy-paste. > It's like calling someone and asking "What time is the meeting?" and they read you a 10-page analysis of calendar management best practices. You asked a simple question. They l…

What makes you think this is AI slop?...

> You asked a simple question. They lobbed a document.

> It's a weapon disguised as helpfulness.

These are particular sentences I find questionable. Would you write that way? I certainly wouldn't.

GPTZero is by no means perfect, but it agreed this was likely generated.

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

90% of people here know what those are.

And with a more broadly applicable example we could share the link with friends, family and coworkers who aren't on HN.

Yes that was exactly my point :)

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#37
post #30

Then at the end, "Use AI to make things clearer". NO! STOP USING AI AND JUST TALK!

I have had experiences where customers use AI to communicate and express their issues. Sometimes they produce walls of text like the website exemplifies, but overall it's a better alternative to not be able to explain the issue because you don't know the specific terminology and you are just a layman trying to do things.

Show some love for the layman, we are all laymen in areas we don't know about.

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#38

This is slop too though, right? > Pasting a massive AI-generated response into a chat or email where a human would write one sentence. It destroys the medium itself. Nobody writes essays in Slack. It's only possible because of AI copy-paste. > It's like calling someone and asking "What time is the meeting?" and they read you a 10-page analysis of calendar management best practices. You asked a simple question. They l…

I found the writing clear, concise, and human.

It's certainly concise but I still remain unconvinced a human wrote it.

> It's a weapon disguised as helpfulness.

The source code is without a doubt AI (it's got a comment for the ""), so I guess one would have to assume they prepared the entire document beforehand, then fed it to Claude and instructed it to use that copy exactly.

...or they prompted "make me a site which tersely criticizes people who post AI slop on Slack, use the term slop grenade and style the site like nohello.net"

Eventually you just get a sense for these things.

Re: Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations

#40

> Nobody writes essays in Slack I 100% write long texts in Slack. I always try to provide as much context as possible when reaching out to someone with a question or request.

Introducing AI made markdown tags for conversations so others can only see what the wanty

Hah, can we do that for recipes next?
Post reply on HN