Live data from Hacker News

Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

phys.org

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#31

I'm always suspicious of "it was religious" claims in archeology.

It is like the go to explanation for things they don't have an answer to. What if the quartz arrow head was just a status symbol or was traded as a luxury item?

Then it would fall under "symbolic or ritual use".

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#32
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're being sarcastic, but aren't you accidentally right? Swiss watchmaking started because local bible-thumpers banned jewelry but made an exception for watches, thus creating demand for watches that fill the role of jewelry. Once established, the industry maintains itself.

Except mechanical watches were very high-tech at the time and were very practical devices. By the time they became mainly an accessory/status symbol sumptuary laws weren’t a thing.

[dead]

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#33
post #4

I'm always suspicious of "it was religious" claims in archeology.

Neither the article nor the backing paper discussed made any such definite claim. Many casual readers confuse statements such as "which *may* have had symbolic or ritual significance." with meaning "this absolutely had to do with (a) religion" when no such thing is intended. Attribution of potential cause of inferred behaviour to "ritual" is a long standing practice in archaeology; it's code for "we don't know" and c…

For examples from more recent history think giant scissors used for ribbon cutting ceremonies, the golden spike used to signal completion of the intercontinental railroad, or like all the stuff related to militaries like changing of the guard that are ceremonial. Or even something like leaving a celebratory emoji on the first or merged by a new hire or a box of donuts on someone's birthday. Or bringing out the champagne after closing on a house. Theres just a ton of ritual in day to day life, and even more surrounding big high impact moments that might leave behind a bunch of artifacts like weddings and funerals

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#34
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're being sarcastic, but aren't you accidentally right? Swiss watchmaking started because local bible-thumpers banned jewelry but made an exception for watches, thus creating demand for watches that fill the role of jewelry. Once established, the industry maintains itself.

Except mechanical watches were very high-tech at the time and were very practical devices. By the time they became mainly an accessory/status symbol sumptuary laws weren’t a thing.

Mechanical watches were always very expensive, and thus were a status symbol from the beginning.

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#35

perhaps the purpose was didactic: when a child gets interested or wants to help those tribe members making stone tools, it is not yet aware of difficulty levels of different materials. teaching a newcomer to make a proper tool from a more annoying material, may make their skills more robust when relaxing to easier materials later on. think of all the skills you had to learn in your own education, and how little of it…

Idea reminds me of these kinds of objects: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbine_cup

Re: Why did Clovis toolmakers choose difficult quartz crystal?

#37
I was out on my daily artifact walk when this was literally posted a few days ago and during that walk I found two broken slightly translucent quartz spear points. Since they were broken they did not make it into my display case next to the whole quartz points but they did make it into my broken relics buckets. Having located more than a thousand native artifacts in the last 14 years of walking I can personally confirm that holding such a visual object in one's own hand causes the mind the ponder and thoughts to roam as the light glistens back into ones eyes. These quartz points also stand alone in appearance next to all my other relics except for the uniques and the perfects.

From the comments too as well I will add that while I have no concrete proof what purpose they served, security or religion, they certainly could kill if used via an atlatl.

Post reply on HN