Live data from Hacker News

Trump Postpones Iran Energy Strikes for Five Days, Citing "Productive" Talks

sharetxt.live

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Trump Postpones Iran Energy Strikes for Five Days, Citing "Productive" Talks

#31
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would the Iranians accept Pahlavi? They don't love the current regime, but overthrowing the Shah was widely popular. I hear that Pahlavi is less bad than his father, but surely somebody in Iran has a claim to leadership without being an obvious American puppet.

I'm just a dude in the southern US, so I obviously don't have first-hand knowledge. The best I can do is speak with my friends and colleagues with ties to Iran; those conversations have led me to believe that Pahlavi is the best option to lead a transitional government. From what I gather it's not that the Iranian people want to return to a Shah, but that Reza has been consistent in stating a desire to lead Iran to a…

I don't think the war is a good idea, and I'm reluctant to recommend outcomes to a culture different from mine.

That said... if it turns out the Pahlavi can bring about an Iran that makes most of its people reasonably happy and free, I'm all for it.

Re: Trump Postpones Iran Energy Strikes for Five Days, Citing "Productive" Talks

#32
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm just a dude in the southern US, so I obviously don't have first-hand knowledge. The best I can do is speak with my friends and colleagues with ties to Iran; those conversations have led me to believe that Pahlavi is the best option to lead a transitional government. From what I gather it's not that the Iranian people want to return to a Shah, but that Reza has been consistent in stating a desire to lead Iran to a…

I don't think the war is a good idea, and I'm reluctant to recommend outcomes to a culture different from mine. That said... if it turns out the Pahlavi can bring about an Iran that makes most of its people reasonably happy and free, I'm all for it.

I do my best to speak about my own political views rarely here, mostly when they're important context to what I'm trying to convey.

> if it turns out the Pahlavi can bring about an Iran that makes most of its people reasonably happy and free, I'm all for it.

Yeah, that's where I am. I'm hoping it works out that way because that's the best path toward a free and happy Iran, not recommending it as a course of action :)

Post reply on HN