Live data from Hacker News

UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

openrightsgroup.org

31–40 of 75 posts

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#31
post #2

So the UK is now China it seems. What a shining light for democracy and justice. There is no way this will be abused by petty little tyrant minister right?

Idk I’ve been watching the occasional BBC archives or some other old archive source, and the UK has seemed relatively authoritarian compared to Europe or the US for a while.

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#32
post #17
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sadly it's not only the UK. There is a global push to restrict communication world-wide. The future is very bleak for fundamental freedoms.

I’m not convinced anymore that we can handle freedom. Many children grow up glued to a phone or tablet watching AI videos and are targets of dis-information from foreign and/or hostile actors.

We can't handle unchecked pursuit of profit, freedom isn't the issue.

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#34

But just a month ago everyone in the discussion about freedom.gov was saying that Europe doesn't restrict internet! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47067270

Well, UK is just one small part of Europe. You probably also confuse Europe and the EU.

Oh, no, not that Europe. You were of course talking about the Europe with Spain (oh wait, La Liga has a cloudflare kill switch). You were of course talking about the Europe with Italy (oh wait, the Piracy Shield). You were of course talking about the Europe with Turkyie (oh wait, ...

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#35

In effect, this is the power to restrict internet to anyone.

It is, and I have no doubt that is the entire point, despite them "thinking of the children."

Im sure the likes of prince andrew and keir starmers advisors think way to much the children

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#36
post #30

So now consider that the same government want to extend voting rights to 16 year olds. So you can vote but you can't control the media you use to learn about who you're potentially voting for. There is something not quite right about that.

[flagged]

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The UK already arrests more than 1,000 a month people for online "hate speech". Higher than the official numbers for China, whatever those are worth. They'll probably reach the unofficial, real number soon enough. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/police-make-30-arr...

Can you give some examples of the speech the UK arrests people for?

https://www.the-independent.com/news/uk/home-news/wales-engl...

You can get arrested for grossly offensive (completely subjective).

Also they have a category called non-crime hate incidents (Hello Kafka) where they come to "intimidate" you without any charges being filed.

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That article was about people suing openAI.

It contains "The plaintiffs allege no age verification took place on the site." As if this is a problem.

As if parents aren't responsible for the actions of their children

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is, and I have no doubt that is the entire point, despite them "thinking of the children."

The Canadian version of this is especially cynical: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c309y25prnlo

To be clear: this is civil action by a family, not the position of the Government of Canada.

Re: UK MPs give ministers powers to restrict Internet for under 18s

#40
post #2

So the UK is now China it seems. What a shining light for democracy and justice. There is no way this will be abused by petty little tyrant minister right?

Idk I’ve been watching the occasional BBC archives or some other old archive source, and the UK has seemed relatively authoritarian compared to Europe or the US for a while.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN