Live data from Hacker News

Those who can, teach history

historytoday.com

31–38 of 38 posts

Re: Those who can, teach history

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shrug. Little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Giving someone tools to create black hole does not ensure that they will be able to utilize that knowledge in a manner that.. is useful. In other words, it may not be absolutely necessary, but it is.. not helpful to suggest accessibility is key. If anything, accessibility makes it dumber; not completely unlike systemD in linux. It serves a purpose, but it dumbs things dow…

Are you seriously suggesting that one can't learn Roman History without learning to read Latin? That it is better to be ignorant of history than read a few books?

I am suggesting exactly what I am suggesting and I opened with those suggestions in the very first post.

By that I mean:

- learn to think critically - learn to apply logic

After that, the world is your oyster, but if you actually want to learn.. and not just.. consume what someone else throws at you, then it will be worthwhile to, you know, learn a thing or two: like, for example, language of the primary sources. I know. I know. There I go gate keeping again.

I will try to narrow it down a little:

"Reading a few books gives you a sketch of an idea someone else had."

Does that help?

Re: Those who can, teach history

#33

Tangential, but what resources would you recommend for learning world history (preferably including the non-Western world as well)? For someone who is not aiming to be an expert or work with source records, but wants to improve their general awareness and erudition.

Getting a broad overview of "world history" is useful for having basic context for large events, but, IMHO, history gets so much more interesting and educational when you're deep into individual people's lives and stories. I'm probably a bit biased, but tend to agree with the suggestions that you pick a time and place and dive deep into an individual or event that catches your fancy.

Re: Those who can, teach history

#35

Tangential, but what resources would you recommend for learning world history (preferably including the non-Western world as well)? For someone who is not aiming to be an expert or work with source records, but wants to improve their general awareness and erudition.

I really like Crash Course World History. I'm older than the target demographic for this resource to be sure, but it's a great high level overview and having this under my belt helped me feel a little more oriented in every other historical thing I've dabbled in since.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBDA2E52FB1EF80C9

Re: Those who can, teach history

#37
post #18

Anyone have an archive link? Despite being a history teacher myself I don't have a historytoday login

By the way, you can simply input archive.today/archive.is/archive.ph before the link and it will either take you to the archived page, or let you archive a new one. Like: archive.is/ https://www.historytoday.com/archive/making-history/those-wh...

Unfortunately this article has not been archived. The only content available at archive.is right now is a stub.

Re: Those who can, teach history

#38

Tangential, but what resources would you recommend for learning world history (preferably including the non-Western world as well)? For someone who is not aiming to be an expert or work with source records, but wants to improve their general awareness and erudition.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN