Live data from Hacker News

GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

thenextweb.com

31–40 of 72 posts

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#31

Can we please use some of that 100 million investment to buy an infrastructure that is more resilient to these kinds of DDoS attacks? Pretty please? This is a service I pay for and my business relies on. Having it down three times in three days impacts our work.

Easier said than done. We've had DDOS issues in the past as well, and getting it resolved - even by throwing money at the problem - is nontrivial.

What amounts to throwing a massive amount of hardware at the problem (i.e., boxes that can handle 10-100+gbps of traffic, filter out the attacks, and pass only legit stuff down to your servers) is expensive[1], and casuses all sorts of unexpected behavior: API clients mysteriously break, good traffic gets mistakenly dropped, latency is added to the whole process, etc. It gets even weirder on SSL-protected sites. And it's all dependent on attackers not getting the IP of your actual servers which they could then just attack directly.

[1] For sites with even not a whole lot of traffic, you're talking a one-year contract easily in the range of an engineer's salary. I wouldn't be surprised if the cost to protect sites with as much traffic as Github exceeded $1m/year. Even if you have plenty of cash in the bank, that's one hell of a pill to swallow.

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#33
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did it really impact your work, other than slightly inconveniencing you? "UGH GitHub down again, I guess I have to go work on something equally as important for upwards of an hour" I call shenanigans on you, good sir.

Since when is it OK for the services I rely on and pay for to even slightly inconvenience me ... for three days in a row? Since never. At least for businesses that want to remain an ongoing concern.

Devil's avocado here: let's say you pay $100/mo for a gym membership and they shut down three days in a row because somebody called in a threat. How upset would you be at the gym?

A malicious attack by a third party is different from, say, the gym allowing black mold to grow in the locker room. I'd quit a gym if they had black mold. That's mismanagement. I wouldn't quit a gym if malicious third party intervention inconvenienced me.

Besides, GitHub is obviously more concerned about this than you or I could ever be. And having money doesn't make infrastructure magically appear.

I pay GitHub too. My company relies on it. I, too, was slightly inconvenienced this week. I was also slightly inconvenienced when I had to make a u-turn because the Battery Tunnel southbound on-ramp was closed. So what?

In summary: shenanigans! Good day sir!

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#34
post #2

Who would try to disable github?

Back in 2009 when it happened to bitbucket, this was afaik due to hosting a particular project (hurting bitbucket was a side effect of hurting this particular project, some communities seems to be happy to resolve issues with DDoS attacks...).

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#36
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did it really impact your work, other than slightly inconveniencing you? "UGH GitHub down again, I guess I have to go work on something equally as important for upwards of an hour" I call shenanigans on you, good sir.

Since when is it OK for the services I rely on and pay for to even slightly inconvenience me ... for three days in a row? Since never. At least for businesses that want to remain an ongoing concern.

If high availability git is so critical then why not run your own git servers instead of or in addition to github?

I find it slightly ironic that the entire point of git is that it is distributed version control but 90% of git use seems to be focused around a product from a single company.

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#39

Maybe it's because I just personally identify with the founders of github (i.e. entrepreneurial sw engineers), but I'm starting to get mad at whoever keeps doing this. Here's hoping that with all the smart people this is affecting, the people responsible will be tracked down and exposed.

If you want to make a service worth a damn to the world, you should expect regular DDOS.

Re: GitHub hit by DDoS attack second day in a row

#40
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone who wants to test the limits of their botnet and technique. Can you think of a more tech savvy target?

Amazon.

Amazon has a service outage every time you look at it funny, much less a DDoS...

hyuk, hyuk

Post reply on HN