Live data from Hacker News

Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

pontozero.info

31–36 of 36 posts

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#31
post #19

Remember when an engaged worldnews moderator got sent to federal prison, because she was Ghislane Maxwell?

Is this actually true? Edit: appears the answer is no.

Look at the writing style comparison between /u/maxwellhill and Gislaine from the Epstein files..

https://www.reddit.com/r/Epstein/comments/1lxvajq/has_anyone...

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#32

Remember when an engaged worldnews moderator got sent to federal prison, because she was Ghislane Maxwell?

For anyone else who was entirely unfamiliar, here's a low-effort search "Incoherent Conspiracy Suggests Ghislaine Maxwell Is a Powerful Redditor" https://www.vice.com/en/article/incoherent-conspiracy-sugges...

A little more effort comparing writing styles shows they're likely the same.. https://www.reddit.com/r/Epstein/comments/1lxvajq/has_anyone...

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There isn’t one “they”, each subreddit does its own moderation

Reddit itself can and still do ban users at site-level.

Which would be fine if there was a good reason to do so but there often isn't

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#34
post #29
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd argue it's more true on Reddit than anywhere. Subreddits are fairly self contained. Other social media sites I feel like I'm fighting off a wave of whatever the site wants / momentum of all the users is. Granted that doesn't mean they're completely isolated, a lot of smaller subs I was a part of have fallen into a mess of spam and engagement bots and so on so my total subs I'm interested in has fallen off.

It used to be the case Reddit itself would run spambots, and if you reported them you'd be banned. Also they have a habit of, if a subreddit isn't moderated how they like, finding excuses to ban the moderators and then either ban the subreddit for being unmoderated or replace the moderators. There were also times they just replaced a moderator list because they didn't like how the subreddit was moderated if there was…

>It used to be the case Reddit itself would run spambots, and if you reported them you'd be banned. Wow, do you have a link to where I could read more about that stuff? I tried doing a quick search, but couldn't find anything. Banning users for reporting bots is a crazy moderation decision...

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#35

Is it really the moderators that make a community special? They are vital no doubt but I have never came here for the moderation . For me the magic of a niche community like a subreddit or HN is when a 99th percentile expert in the subject shows up and gives everybody a brilliant lecture on the actual truth of things. These are not 99th percentile in Reddit use or post count or any of those things.

Moderators are the invisible hand pruning the garden weeds. You might not always see them working, but they allow the space necessary for the good conversations to grow and thrive. Their absence would be felt quickly.

Re: Reddit Has Become the Internet's Strip Mall

#36
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It used to be the case Reddit itself would run spambots, and if you reported them you'd be banned. Also they have a habit of, if a subreddit isn't moderated how they like, finding excuses to ban the moderators and then either ban the subreddit for being unmoderated or replace the moderators. There were also times they just replaced a moderator list because they didn't like how the subreddit was moderated if there was…

>It used to be the case Reddit itself would run spambots, and if you reported them you'd be banned. Wow, do you have a link to where I could read more about that stuff? I tried doing a quick search, but couldn't find anything. Banning users for reporting bots is a crazy moderation decision...

Since it happened several years ago it would be hard to find now. Here's a different, related issue that I did find (with links to several more threads): https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/17bkv3f/false_b...
Post reply on HN