Live data from Hacker News

Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

bbc.com

31–40 of 89 posts

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#31

Children social media bans are just an excuse to deanonymize the internet so politicians can send the police after their critics. https://anzsog.edu.au/research-insights-and-resources/resear...

The ban is supported by a large majority of Australia according to polling, so this is democracy working as intended.

[dead]

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I haven’t looked, but I’m assuming this ban already applies to YouTube, right? Apparently someone from the government looks at the site and assesses how 'core' the online social interaction is to the site. Banned: Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Threads, TikTok, X, YouTube, Reddit, Kick and Twitch Not banned (yet): Pintrest, YouTube Kids, Google Classroom, WhatsApp, Discord, online games like Roblox, AI chat. https:…

This list indeed seems to be a random selection

Being a parent myself, the list is not random. The ones in the banned list deserve to be there. I would argue Youtube Kids needs to be banned too.

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#34
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Problem is, that it sets a precedent, and next they will come for other websites whose ban will strike you as "bad". Edit: I can definitely see them banning anything related to Linux and resources related to OSes because of how processes can be handled, e.g. "kill parent", "kill child", and so on. The term "kill" already has to be censored out on many websites. Of course context matters, but people really have diffic…

You can use this train of thought to argue against laws in general, it doesn't sound like a very strong argument

Within this context, how? I do not think it can be used to argue against laws in general. Plus we have a lot of experiences now about it setting a precedent and them coming for your beloved websites. It is not even debatable today.

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#35
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This list indeed seems to be a random selection

Being a parent myself, the list is not random. The ones in the banned list deserve to be there. I would argue Youtube Kids needs to be banned too.

Discord and Roblox are probably the grooming/edating center of the net right now. The banned ones are just SFW sites where they can see some titties.

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#36
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This list indeed seems to be a random selection

Being a parent myself, the list is not random. The ones in the banned list deserve to be there. I would argue Youtube Kids needs to be banned too.

IF the filters actually worked for youtube kids then i would not have an issue with it, some very low effort AI crap keep showing up with the latest brain rot song so i agree.

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#37
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Problem is, that it sets a precedent, and next they will come for other websites whose ban will strike you as "bad". Edit: I can definitely see them banning anything related to Linux and resources related to OSes because of how processes can be handled, e.g. "kill parent", "kill child", and so on. The term "kill" already has to be censored out on many websites. Of course context matters, but people really have diffic…

You can use this train of thought to argue against laws in general, it doesn't sound like a very strong argument

First they forbade kids to smoke, and I said nothing

Then they forbade kids to drink, and I said nothing

Then they prevented kids to watch porn, I said nothing

And when the time came for me to complain about the price of cigarettes and booze, there weren't any kids to say anything.

Or something like that

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#38

Banned for the wrong reason. It's a cam girl site targeted at kids.

Its not a cam girl site targeted at kids. There are thousands of streamers on the platform playing different games. I do agree that the pool / beach section should be closed but honestly its a minority (look at the viewer stats - kids can get porn a lot easier then twitch). Also, that section is not targeted at kids, its targeted at adults in nations with anti porn laws, which gets apparent when you look at who is donating to the streamers.

Re: Streaming platform Twitch added to Australia's teen social media ban

#39
post #2

On the one hand I’m glad HN doesn’t do embedded images, on the other I’d really like to see this thread just be popcorn eating GIFs. It’ll certainly be interesting to see how this plays out - I feel like Twitch reaches such a large and diverse demographic that the response will be palpable. I haven’t looked, but I’m assuming this ban already applies to YouTube, right?

> I haven’t looked, but I’m assuming this ban already applies to YouTube, right? Apparently someone from the government looks at the site and assesses how 'core' the online social interaction is to the site. Banned: Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Threads, TikTok, X, YouTube, Reddit, Kick and Twitch Not banned (yet): Pintrest, YouTube Kids, Google Classroom, WhatsApp, Discord, online games like Roblox, AI chat. https:…

Steam straddles the line between gaming and social too.
Post reply on HN