Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

anthropic.com

31–40 of 129 posts

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#31
post #15
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you seen their 2025 growth curve (and projections)? https://www.reddit.com/r/EconomyCharts/comments/1lwdwd6/anth...

Growth curves mean nothing if you're selling $0.90 dollars. You have to show a growth curve when price > cost. It's not even clear that value > cost. I absolutely love Anthropic; but I am worried about the fiscal wall they will hit that will ratchet up my opex as they will need to steeply raise prices.

So the critical question here really is whether they are selling API access to their models for less than the unit cost it takes to serve them.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even better, don’t just “allow”, but force them to create power plants equal in size to their usage. Must be renewable.

I don't care what they use. Nuclear preferred but whatever works for the area. Natural gas is the main reason our emissions have gone down as it replaces coal. Also I don't think forcing is necessary. These datacenters want to, why impose more regulations.

[deleted]

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win. There is another way forward, which is not building these data centers, forcing AI companies to use power more efficiently, and use the excess energy production capacity towards the energy transition in order to avoid the worst consequences of climate change. It's not going to happen, at least not right now, but it's clearly what we ought to do. ChatGPT can wa…

I think you may be missing the whole national security part of the AI race. This isn't just about asking a computer what recipe you can cook tonight with the items in your fridge. In many ways it is similar to the race to build a nuclear bomb. We may individually not like that, but we might individually be best served to live in the nation that got there first.

Building gigantic data centers doesn't help in that respect. The data centers are there to do inference at scale, not cutting edge research.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#34
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win. There is another way forward, which is not building these data centers, forcing AI companies to use power more efficiently, and use the excess energy production capacity towards the energy transition in order to avoid the worst consequences of climate change. It's not going to happen, at least not right now, but it's clearly what we ought to do. ChatGPT can wa…

Why should they be treated differently than any other customer?

Because we live on a finite planet and unregulated capitalism won't end well.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the administration is allowing datacenters to be utilities and build their own power plants, nuclear or otherwise. the excess can be sold to the grid. it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win.

How many times has that happened so far?

Google is working with Kairos Power for nuclear reactors at their datacenters.

Microsoft struck a deal with Three Mile Island to get a reactor up.

And Amazon is working with Talen Energy.

Might be others I missed.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even better, don’t just “allow”, but force them to create power plants equal in size to their usage. Must be renewable.

I don't care what they use. Nuclear preferred but whatever works for the area. Natural gas is the main reason our emissions have gone down as it replaces coal. Also I don't think forcing is necessary. These datacenters want to, why impose more regulations.

Your grandchildren will care if they use coal or natural gas.

Aim higher. Do better.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#38

We still need to fix the problem with powering these Datacenters....

the administration is allowing datacenters to be utilities and build their own power plants, nuclear or otherwise. the excess can be sold to the grid. it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win.

The real win/win would be to require them to build enough solar to power the operation.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#39
post #31
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Growth curves mean nothing if you're selling $0.90 dollars. You have to show a growth curve when price > cost. It's not even clear that value > cost. I absolutely love Anthropic; but I am worried about the fiscal wall they will hit that will ratchet up my opex as they will need to steeply raise prices.

So the critical question here really is whether they are selling API access to their models for less than the unit cost it takes to serve them.

But inference is cheap! If they stop doing everything and become Inference Inc., they'll be profitable.

Re: Anthropic invests $50B in US AI infrastructure

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the administration is allowing datacenters to be utilities and build their own power plants, nuclear or otherwise. the excess can be sold to the grid. it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win.

> it's really the only way forward. seems like a win/win. There is another way forward, which is not building these data centers, forcing AI companies to use power more efficiently, and use the excess energy production capacity towards the energy transition in order to avoid the worst consequences of climate change. It's not going to happen, at least not right now, but it's clearly what we ought to do. ChatGPT can wa…

> forcing AI companies to use power more efficiently

How? Also, why? Why are datacentres the use to tamp down on versus other industrial and commercial uses?

This reminds me of California rationing residential water use so alfalfa farmers can flood their fields.

Post reply on HN