Live data from Hacker News

My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#31

>detective/case solving TV, fantasy Elder Scrolls (Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim) and Soulsborne (Demons Souls, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, Elden Ring) games both have lots of mysterious lore and fantasy elements. Maybe the lore videos would help her appreciate the art? Lore videos could also pique her interest in a video game without her actually having to play it, which could be a gateway to eventually getting a contolle…

The music for Bloodborne is incredible. If this isn't art, I don't know what is.

https://youtu.be/LzdhTGaWzec

https://youtu.be/NHIkUzmNmc0

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#33

Presumably she is young enough to have completely missed out on Myst, which will be very dated now but was groundbreaking at the time and is most definitely a work of art. These puzzle games are all very distinctive and beautiful in my opinion: - Limbo - Manifold Garden - Monument Valley I think on its face the question “can video games be art?” Is both absurd and obviously answered. The question are their games your…

Thank you! Go for the original or the remake?

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#34

If she has little experience with video games, Journey and Gris might be good candidates. For a more "technical" argument how gameplay mechanics can be a unique way to deliver an emotion to the player (arguably a major part in the role of art): Brothers: A Tale of two Sons. You'd have to make sure that she finishes it, though (estimate: ~3h). Two trippy games that defy categorization (but won't be good examples for s…

Never heard of any of these. Checked them out and they all look great. Hard to decide but I think I will include one of yours. Thanks a ton!
Post reply on HN