Live data from Hacker News

Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

corporate.walmart.com

31–40 of 153 posts

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#31
post #20
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

they might not drink water

Most likely so if they buy their food at walmart.

It's extremely presumptuous of you to assume that everyone who shops at Walmart are uneducated simpletons.

Maybe they're smarter than you with money. The same box of cereal that costs less than $2 at Walmart is almost $6 at Whole Foods.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#32
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It makes sense to evaluate the health effects of individual dyes I wonder if changing the color of food is actually that important.

Ah, yes. The "I don't think anyone needs to do this, therefore no one needs to do this" argument.

Hardly. I'm openly wondering. If you _need_ to do this, then please, by all means, share that with us here now.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#33
Generally, I tend to eat natural foods. I have for decades. They just taste better. Dyes are mostly used in processed foods, because otherwise they would look unappealing next to fresh natural food. And for a very good reason.

All that is to say, doesn't much matter to me what they regulate, I eat hardly any of that stuff anyway.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#34
post #5

My understanding is that there are somewhat more restrictive regulations on food dyes in the EU compared to the US. But that overall there isn't a big concern about the majority of these dyes. There also isn't a fundamental difference between a synthetic and a natural dye. Okay, humans are more likely to have encountered a natural dye during their evolution and adapted to ingesting them. But that is unlikely to matte…

There are people with allergies to some naturally derived dyes. Annatto (from tree seeds) and carmine (from bugs) in particular.

A small number of people get anaphylaxis from carmine.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#35
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But this is likely also an attempt to market to people who think things like "but I don't want to be exposed to chemicals" while not realizing water is a chemical.

This is the kind of nerd-snark that makes normal people not trust anything from the mouths of "experts." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovKw6YjqSfM

[flagged]

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#36
If China stops buying our soybeans, we can start planting other things. Aren't natural food dyes just a great way to encourage diversity in domestic agriculture?

I am not an expert in synthetic vs. natural, but I feel like this decision isn't actually about health (I don't see any reason to believe why Wal-Mart cares at all about the health of Americans) but rather some larger macroeconomic reality.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#37
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The sheer percentage of artificial food dyes that have been banned suggests otherwise. There’s a long pattern of banning something once enough evidence builds up only to be replaced by something that’s then eventually banded. If there where significant value that might be different, but there isn’t a great argument for experimenting on millions of people here.

How many artificial food dyes have been actually banned? I mean in the time where we actually had some regulations, the old days were quite wild in terms of safety in all areas, so I don't think that would be a useful comparison.

I'm in awe at the number of people that will go to bat for things like artificial dyes in food, only because the policy is coming from the present administration. It's just common sense. We don't need to be ingesting this shit. It's cosmetic and not needed for nutrition. Why are you feeding your child Fruit Loops and not Cheerios?

I personally have known people who develop migraines after eating food with artificial dyes. We can sit here and snipe and play semantics and argue over pointless details but why bother? Just get rid of them all.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#38

Synthetic and “natural” is so hazy. What’s the difference between a dye that’s synthetically made and one where we crush up bugs and extract the same exact chemical (real thing.). Why don’t we just eliminate most dyes overall…

You will eat the bugs...

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#39
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But this is likely also an attempt to market to people who think things like "but I don't want to be exposed to chemicals" while not realizing water is a chemical.

This is the kind of nerd-snark that makes normal people not trust anything from the mouths of "experts." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovKw6YjqSfM

The thing is, there are many chemicals which are safe to drink in reasonable amounts, and many chemicals that are not safe to drink in any amount. People deciding not to eat something because "it has chemicals in it" is a pretty ignorant take.

Re: Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods

#40

Synthetic and “natural” is so hazy. What’s the difference between a dye that’s synthetically made and one where we crush up bugs and extract the same exact chemical (real thing.). Why don’t we just eliminate most dyes overall…

You will eat the bugs...

I have some bad news for you if that bothers you https://www.livescience.com/36292-red-food-dye-bugs-cochinea.... That’s where “natural” dye comes from
Post reply on HN