Live data from Hacker News

Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 67 posts

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#32
I stop caring about Gentoo in 2005, classical distros do the job, I also don't care about nix and guix.

Everyone is naturally free to use whatever they feel like, some people never open the hood on their cars, while others might even melt bolts to fix their oldtimers themselves.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#34
Gentoo was how I learned Linux. In college, I used it on my desktop (alongside Windows) and I remember thinking I was a "1337 h4xx0r" by compiling my kernel and setting the flags to make everything custom for my PC. I remember having compile errors and having to try to fix it, even though I didn't know much about C/C++.

I enjoyed using Gentoo and I eventually set up distcc on a separate computer to help compiling.

I forget exactly when, but I switched to Arch Linux and after a failed upgrade there, switched again to Fedora.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#37
Arch is less flexible but AUR wins for me over overlays. I find writing and modifying Arch pkgbuild a lot easier than Gentoo ebuild.

Ebuild offers a lot of functions and "magic" which looks nice in theory but actually means you will be lost if you don't write them often. Arch pkgbuild look like a shell script. Adding a random patch to an existing package is extremely easy.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#39
Gentoo and Linux from Scratch (LFS) were a great way to learn back in the day (yes, 20-some years ago) — and support relatively custom operating environments through USE flags (e.g., which flavor of Motif did I want to use). I found Gentoo to be a rather practical low-level tradeoff in that era compared to Debian (super old package set and release cadence). You have to bear in mind: there were plenty of Gentoo users out there who weren't into abusing CFLAGS and such. And Portage had such a low bar to climb to create a package (cf. Debian Policy Manual as a description of the arcane nature of Debian package management with dh). Moreover, Ubuntu, which was a good pressure on Debian to modernize, wasn't yet on the mainstream for a good window of time when Gentoo really took off.

Re: Gentoo Linux might be the best desktop Linux distro for advanced Linux users

#40
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you confusing Debian and Ubuntu?

> Are you confusing Debian and Ubuntu? No, you're confusing exclusivity. https://launchpad.net/debian/+ppas

No, I know PPA's are just a way of telling apt about a repository.

What I mean is that Debian does not support adding PPA by default island I frankly don't hear of many Debian users doing that. Flatpak/-hub is much more common.

Post reply on HN