Live data from Hacker News

U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

torrentfreak.com

31–40 of 268 posts

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#31
post #25
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can we get a list of senators who support this and their party affiliation?

Thom Tillis - R Chris Coons - D Marsha Blackburn - R Adam Schiff - D

Schiff is (D)

Worth noting that this was introduced by Zoe Lofgren (D) the 77 year old that represents a big chunk of Silicon Valley. Disappointing.

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#34
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thom Tillis - R Chris Coons - D Marsha Blackburn - R Adam Schiff - D

Schiff is (D) Worth noting that this was introduced by Zoe Lofgren (D) the 77 year old that represents a big chunk of Silicon Valley. Disappointing.

He is! Thank you.

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#35

No one would steal a car. More importantly, everyone would clone a car. Of course we should support this fully. Oppose this bill.

Oppose the bill based on freedom, as in speech. This comes above all else.

Arguing over what is or isn't piracy is a non-sequitor when it comes to government censorship of the Internet.

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#36

I've been trying to watch old 80s-90s movies recently. I'm happy to pay $5 or whatever, and they just aren't available anywhere. Rental stores are dead, so I can't go rent them from blockbuster or whatever, and streaming sites have splintered to the point I'm not even sure what is a scam and what is a legitimate business anymore. Trying to even find availability of what films exist on which streaming sites has been a…

How's your local library system?

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#37
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Both major parties are corpo-authoritarian, with the main dynamics of elections being to gauge how much the public is willing to accept and to make half the people think they actually wanted the resulting policies. And for this round the people have spoken that they want it good and hard.

I don’t think they care about the policy. They just see a one sided debate: companies will to pay and an indifferent public.

Sure, you're up against "the purpose of a system is what it does". I'm sure many mainstream politicians actually earnestly care about individual liberty and reigning in corpos - it helps them sell themselves to the public. But the net effect is that when the dollars come calling, enough set aside those ideals to make the corpo agenda happen.

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#38

Isn't torrenting way down from its heyday? Streaming companies are not perfect, but I always thought they were at least moderately successful such that in 2025, average, casual, non-techies no longer bother to jump through the VPN and private tracker hoops just to download a movie.

For a while, streaming was better than any alternative. However over the last several year prices have a spike while the collections available for streaming have shrunk and splintered. Then a bunch of the streaming sites started adding ads for their paying customers.

At this point streaming servcies have been enshitified enough to make piracy again the better experience.

Re: U.S. senators introduce new pirate site blocking bill, "Block BEARD"

#39
> The granted orders would stay in place for a year with the option to extend if necessary. If blocked sites switch to new locations, the court can also amend blocking orders to include new IP addresses and domain names.

What if the "pirate site" uses foreign cloud provider, and regularly changes IP addresses? Will I lose access to all websites hosted by the foreign cloud provider once their whole ASN will be blocked?

> Block BEARD does not mention VPNs, but its broad definition of “service provider” could be interpreted to include them.

This seems easy to circumvent - you can just use foreign VPN provider, who don't advertise themselves for piracy use, for... piracy. IP/DNS blocking proven to be a good censorship tool though.

Post reply on HN