Live data from Hacker News

Google's widespread tracking across the web

simpleanalytics.com

31–40 of 108 posts

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#31

> Even in countries with strict laws like the GDPR, Google's trackers are still everywhere. That raises questions about how effective these regulations really are in practice. This is basically it. GDPR is a stupid unenforceable law, and should be wiped from the books. Try again with something new.

It took a while, but is starting to work.

Many "cookie banners" have finally started to work in the EU. Once you deny PII processing many sites don't load GA etc... The time of malicious compliance is starting to pass. Some sites have figured it out and realized they really don't need personalized analytics and have replaced implementations with privacy respecting ones(ex, plausible). This lets them remove the dark-patternish banner and no additional consent is required as all data is pooled together and one persons actions truly can't be singled out.

GDPR obviously has other good effects but as PII processing through cookies is what most people know, I chose that as an example. Email tracking links & pixels are another good example.

There's also a big difference between 2018 and 2025 when discussing GDPR in work contexts and saying that implementing this or that tracking would be illegal.

It's a slow process, but it's working as intended.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#33
post #24

User tracking only exists because it generates money. We should ban the entire practice. No more targeted ads (with very little exceptions).

how you can ban the practice??? in what way ?

You ban it by making it illegal.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#35
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You ban it by making it illegal.

how can you make it illegal?? >make a new law >they just move elsewhere how??? tell me

The EU was pretty successful with mandating cookie banners and GDPR.

On the other hand, I think a great firewall would be useful to the US and especially the EU, to be able to enforce their laws even better.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#36
post #2

This title is highly misleading, implying that Google tracks DuckDuckGo searches directly, which isn’t true. It also reinforces a conspiracy theory that we’re owned by Google, which also of course isn’t true. Kindly please change it to be more accurate about Google analytics and other Google trackers on websites you may visit. We’ve been sounding the alarm about Google analytics, tag manager, and other Google tracker…

The threat is real though and I've recently noticed an uptick in the google SSO popup, which is just another way of tracking. Most notably on pornhub. I'm not too keen to let them know what I have a wank to.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah. This is simple fear mongering to sell its own analytics product.

Hopefully you won’t mind me using their own arguments to promote this OSS web analytics project instead: https://counterscale.dev/ Unlike Simple Analytics (the post authors), you deploy Counterscale to your own Cloudflare account and control the code + data end-to-end. It also uses no cookies, has no browser fingerprinting, and has no monetized SaaS offering. It only has 90 days retention though, which could be viewe…

I am all for the hustle. Startups are difficult. So, even though I don't like the post, I understand it is done because it works.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#38
post #6

Let's face reality: as soon as you browse the internet, you will be tracked and identified. Here are just a few data points used for fingerprinting: IP address, User-Agent string, Referrer URL, Requested URL, Language, Locale, Screen resolution, Time zone, System time, Installed fonts, Installed plugins, Cookie data, Browser fingerprint, Canvas fingerprint, WebGL fingerprint, AudioContext fingerprint, Mouse movements…

How is the MAC collected?

MAC is easily spoofed, most smartphones do it already by default - although only per session

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#39
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Depending on your network configuration I could imagine abuse of EDNS(0). This is used for example by NextDNS to identify which device (MAC) on your local network sent the request in order to apply specific filters and log the request. A not-so-friendly DNS could sell such information.

I use dnscrypt with a supposedly secure configuration, is that not enough to counteract this?

Ask your friendly local CIA agent, not us. We don't have access to that intel.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

how can you make it illegal?? >make a new law >they just move elsewhere how??? tell me

The EU was pretty successful with mandating cookie banners and GDPR. On the other hand, I think a great firewall would be useful to the US and especially the EU, to be able to enforce their laws even better.

"mandating cookie banners and GDPR."

this is only works if your business located in EU, no one stop EU people visit US site and still get tracked

Post reply on HN