Live data from Hacker News

Facebook is just Craigslist now

theatlantic.com

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#31

In the US - sure. The rest of the world -lol, no

Yeah, at least anecdotally that's true from my observation. I grew up in the US but spent time living abroad, so have networks in multiple places. American friends ditched the site en masse starting around 2012. By now, none of my original American circle is using the site and my timeline/feed is entirely dead except for frequent posts by foreigner friends.

There are some countries where Facebook is the internet as far as they’re concerned

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For ~a decade, Facebook replaced the address book. You wouldn't ask for a phone number; you'd add someone on Facebook. They got greedy. Word got out about how they'd manipulate the algorithm to get you to spend hours per day there, how aggressively they mined and sold your data, etc. It became unfashionable to use. People who had spent a decade recording their lives and connecting with their friends walked away from…

It's hard to explain to Zoomers/younger people how cool Facebook was in the late 2000s to early 2010s. It was the de facto digital means of communication for social events--the social world in your palm so you could see what everyone was up to, where the parties were, whatever. I signed on recently (mostly to make sure my creds still worked after at least 7 years of no use) and now it's dreadfully slow and largely ju…

>It was the de facto digital means of communication for social events--the social world in your palm so you could see what everyone was up to, where the parties were, whatever.

I think Zuck realized pretty fast that specialized competition is coming that's why he scooped up Instagram and WhatsApp so fast. Without Instagram and WhatsApp, Facebook is botched, something like Google without Chrome and Android. I really can't see how Facebook can become relevant again, their time is gone, people got tired of it. Like you said it was awesome back in the day because it was the first real social network and everybody was on Facebook but nowadays no way 90% of your friends are on Facebook. They are scattered around, mostly on Instagram, WhatsApp and Snapchat. Zuck got lease on life when he acquired Instagram and WhatsApp because they are still relevant and will be for quite some time.

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't that what nextdoor is? I have no firsthand experience but hear it talked about.

Nextdoor has cornered the racist busybody market but nothing beyond that.

That's how I imagine facebook but haven't been there in years.

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's hard to explain to Zoomers/younger people how cool Facebook was in the late 2000s to early 2010s. It was the de facto digital means of communication for social events--the social world in your palm so you could see what everyone was up to, where the parties were, whatever. I signed on recently (mostly to make sure my creds still worked after at least 7 years of no use) and now it's dreadfully slow and largely ju…

>It was the de facto digital means of communication for social events--the social world in your palm so you could see what everyone was up to, where the parties were, whatever. I think Zuck realized pretty fast that specialized competition is coming that's why he scooped up Instagram and WhatsApp so fast. Without Instagram and WhatsApp, Facebook is botched, something like Google without Chrome and Android. I really c…

> really can't see how Facebook can become relevant again, their time is gone, people got tired of it.

Yeah my thoughts exactly.

I really can't tell who or what it's supposed to be for. It seems almost anachronistic--I still have such a positive association with the name because of fond memories of what it was ~12-15 years ago. Ironically it's only that was as I've hardly used it in a decade.

Come to think of it, it probably has something to do with the timing--it was a cornerstone of Millennial youth and the emergence of social media when it was still a new idea and before, well, everything that's happened since.

I really wonder what the actual user metrics are by type of engagement and age now (not some nonsense like DAU or something that captures an occasional idle scroll or background process).

Maybe it's just my American-centric view and it's used more worldwide? I remember messenger being a big thing for some time too, but I think that's also faded?

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#36
post #12

All I ever hear about Facebook any more is just its marketplace. It's gotten to the point where I might make an account just so I can easily sell stuff locally.

I made an account to sell a cheap guitar. I listed it for $100 and used all my own original pictures. They said my listing was suspicious and needed to verify my identity, which meant sending them a picture of me holding my drivers license next to my face. I had a lot of other stuff to sell, so I obliged. They said that wasn’t enough and they required another photo, this time holding my passport by my head. I thought…

I have only briefly had a Facebook, maybe 2 or 3 times, most recently to sell/giveaway a bunch of stuff before a house move.

It was simple, easy, and reliable.

Re: Facebook is just Craigslist now

#37
post #12

All I ever hear about Facebook any more is just its marketplace. It's gotten to the point where I might make an account just so I can easily sell stuff locally.

I made an account to sell a cheap guitar. I listed it for $100 and used all my own original pictures. They said my listing was suspicious and needed to verify my identity, which meant sending them a picture of me holding my drivers license next to my face. I had a lot of other stuff to sell, so I obliged. They said that wasn’t enough and they required another photo, this time holding my passport by my head. I thought…

You should have created an obviously fake account called like "Mark Guy" with a photo of an asian woman and you should have posted some nazi stuff. In that case your account would have been completely fine for them.
Post reply on HN