Live data from Hacker News

Mechanical Engineer creates instruments for his one-man metal band (2022)

revolvermag.com

31–33 of 33 posts

Re: Mechanical Engineer creates instruments for his one-man metal band (2022)

#31
post #19

It's not industrial or metal but here's an obligatory link to Wintergatan's Marble Machine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvUU8joBb1Q

And for a slightly different take on mechanically made music here's Quentin and His Bird Box Orchestra featuring His 18th Century Hand Teacher: https://youtube.com/watch?v=gbX6lm-DZ4g

Ah, weird part of the internet, we meet again…

Re: Mechanical Engineer creates instruments for his one-man metal band (2022)

#32
post #8
post #3

I'm a fan of his music and respect his aesthetics. But, these are not musical instruments. They are mostly MIDI controllers. They don't actually generate sound with mechanical means. They are theater props.

I don’t see how the fact that they make sound digitally in any way makes them less of an instrument. MIDI controllers are instruments- and incredibly flexible ones with almost limitless sound possibilities at that.

I have several midi controllers. They are not instruments. I have many instruments (including vst's) that have controllers on them. Apart from my old rackmount Korg Wavestation a/d I have several instruments without controllers.

Re: Mechanical Engineer creates instruments for his one-man metal band (2022)

#33
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t see how the fact that they make sound digitally in any way makes them less of an instrument. MIDI controllers are instruments- and incredibly flexible ones with almost limitless sound possibilities at that.

I have several midi controllers. They are not instruments. I have many instruments (including vst's) that have controllers on them. Apart from my old rackmount Korg Wavestation a/d I have several instruments without controllers.

The old concept of an instrument does not map well to electronic music equipment- perhaps it would make sense to say that the combination of the input device that interacts with your body, and the computer or synthesizer are together a single instrument? In the same way that all of the different parts of a guitar are one instrument.
Post reply on HN