Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Tiling with Three Polygons Is Undecidable

arxiv.org

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Tiling with Three Polygons Is Undecidable

#31

Post by nuancebydefault »

sfn42 wrote: post #26
Mountain_Skies wrote: post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Every year we hear about some kid who is "smarter than Einstein and Hawking" but for the most part, we never hear about them again. Child prodigies that turn into extraordinary adults seem to be rare. If you were to ask me to name some, the only one I'd be able to name off hand would be Stephen Wolfram. That here is another one is of interest even if it is of little consequence to his current accomplishments.

I think the bar has been raised. As science has progressed and evolved, all the "low hanging fruit" has been picked. As an example, take Dijkstra's algorithm. It's far from the only thing that he is known for and I am by no means trying to diminish his accomplishments but how many people really tried to solve that problem before him? I might be subject to some kind of fallacy or bias but I feel like if I'd never hear…

Maybe Archimedes was not so smart after all. Especially since he was forced to think.

Re: Tiling with Three Polygons Is Undecidable

#32

Post by sfn42 »

nuancebydefault wrote: post #31
sfn42 wrote: post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the bar has been raised. As science has progressed and evolved, all the "low hanging fruit" has been picked. As an example, take Dijkstra's algorithm. It's far from the only thing that he is known for and I am by no means trying to diminish his accomplishments but how many people really tried to solve that problem before him? I might be subject to some kind of fallacy or bias but I feel like if I'd never hear…

Maybe Archimedes was not so smart after all. Especially since he was forced to think.

I'm not saying they're not smart, I'm saying it takes more than just a smart man. If Einstein was born in Africa to a family barely scraping by, and never got an education do you think he'd have come up with his theory of relativity? That's a rhetorical question, it's pretty much just a fact that he wouldn't. So you need the genius, you need the education and all the other social infrastructure, lots of circumstance.

Also I'm saying that nobody can come up with the theory of relativity again. That big juicy fruit is picked. I'm not saying it was low hanging, but it also wasn't at the top of the tree. Maybe if someone else figured out relativity and Einstein was born 40 years ago he would just be another relatively unknown physicist today. Maybe he'd have figured out some other amazing revolutionary thing, who knows. He certainly wouldn't have been the one to figure out relativity if it had already been done.

Post reply on HN