Live data from Hacker News

Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

kaeruct.github.io

31–40 of 81 posts

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#31
Obsidian's business model might be genius. Open file formats; closed source.

By making a great product, they attract users. Usually the main argument against software like this is vendor lock-in. But by using open formats, there's always an escape hatch. If they decided to squeeze their users, I suspect a decent open source alternative would pop up very quickly. In the meantime, casual open source alternatives are very unlikely to catch up in terms of quality and features, because they don't have a funded team working on them full time.

On the flipside, Obsidian is incentivized to keep their customers happy, because their moat isn't so large as to allow complete complacency.

Overall some of the best aligned incentives I've seen. Though it does make me sad because I feel like we almost never see this good of balance in open source software.

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#32
post #4

Site is nearly unreadable on an iPhone or Firefox on Windows, showing up with a dark background and dark text. Something broken in the CSS?

If you're already using Firefox, all you have to do is click the Reader Mode button, at the right edge of your URL bar.

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-reader-view-clu...

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#33
post #7

This website is a good test of who actually clicked the link, not able to read a thing, coming back to the comments to report the bad experience, and who didn't click the link/is a bot, talking about the article as if nothing happened.

I came to the comments to see if it was just me. Dark gray on black seemed bad it had to be a rendering issue, but at the same time, background color and color seem like the CSS that would always work.

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#34
post #18
post #7

This website is a good test of who actually clicked the link, not able to read a thing, coming back to the comments to report the bad experience, and who didn't click the link/is a bot, talking about the article as if nothing happened.

Looks fine on mobile

Which mobile? I’m on Safari on iOS and it’s bad.

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#35
post #7

This website is a good test of who actually clicked the link, not able to read a thing, coming back to the comments to report the bad experience, and who didn't click the link/is a bot, talking about the article as if nothing happened.

This comment is a good example of people coming up with bad tests: reader mode exists, you know, and non-bots can use it

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

https://code.visualstudio.com/download

Visual Studio Code binaries from Microsoft's website is proprietary [1] even though their source code is available under the MIT License. VSCodium provides MIT License builds with Microsoft telemetry removed [2][3].

[1] https://code.visualstudio.com/license

[2] https://vscodium.com/

[3] https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/releases

Re: Migrating from DokuWiki to Obsidian

#38
I have used and loved both DokuWiki and Obsidian (although I use Joplin these days). As the author noted, DokuWiki is best with collaborators and when public facing. However I've found a Git repo with Markdown files that link to eachother makes a killer decentralized collaborative KB. Add to that forges like GitHub/GitLab/Codeberg which render the markdown and list the files in your browser and it's truly great.
Post reply on HN