Live data from Hacker News

The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

urbanproxima.com

31–40 of 66 posts

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#31
> It will also result in housing that looks like a stack of shipping containers.

This is an either temporally or willfully ignorant statement - prefabricated housing hasn’t had to look like a boring box in decades. I’ve been involved in prefab projects where you couldn’t tell the on-site builds from the prefabs.

Also there’s an elevation rendering of the project that clearly isn’t ’a stack of shipping containers’.

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#32
post #17

As a former (well, still card holding) union laborer I have to express my displeasure at Costco circumventing the prevailing wage requirements by building modular sections offsite and trucking them in. Other than that, I like the mixed use approach to this building.

If only housing could be more expensive

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#33
post #4

I'm continuously impressed by Costco. Not only is it one of my favorite places to shop, but I also recently recent to the Acquired episode on Costco[0] and was super impressed by how they run their business. They've continuously been able to align their unique advantages to reenforce each other and make their advantages even stronger. I highly recommend this episode to everyone. [0] https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/c…

> their unique advantages What are those? I never really found any sort of "unique advantage" of Costco. Certainly nothing to drive the extra distance past Sam's. While I had a membership, it was largely more expensive or didn't have what I wanted.

Every product at Costco is vetted or experimental. Either way, you’ll always be happy because if you don’t like it they have their eternal refund policy (refund at any time without a time limit)

The product return rates are also tied to customer data (membership scanning is required to pay). The better return data allows them to make better decisions on which products to boot.

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#34
post #17

As a former (well, still card holding) union laborer I have to express my displeasure at Costco circumventing the prevailing wage requirements by building modular sections offsite and trucking them in. Other than that, I like the mixed use approach to this building.

If only housing could be more expensive

I find it curious that people generally applaud Costco for paying good wages to their workers yet don't extend that consideration to those who build the stores.

Is it latent classism? Disdain for tradespeople? Is outsourcing bad when it comes for office jobs, but good when it shaves a few percent off of the final $/ft2?

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#35

> It will also result in housing that looks like a stack of shipping containers. This is an either temporally or willfully ignorant statement - prefabricated housing hasn’t had to look like a boring box in decades. I’ve been involved in prefab projects where you couldn’t tell the on-site builds from the prefabs. Also there’s an elevation rendering of the project that clearly isn’t ’a stack of shipping containers’.

That was what struck me. Sure it could look like shipping containers, but that seems very uncharitable.

Without plans or a render showing that’s the case I don’t know why we can’t assume it would be at least a little better looking.

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> their unique advantages What are those? I never really found any sort of "unique advantage" of Costco. Certainly nothing to drive the extra distance past Sam's. While I had a membership, it was largely more expensive or didn't have what I wanted.

Gas is cheaper. Pharmacy is cheaper, whether you have insurance or not. Perhaps more so if you don't have insurance. The regular stuff is good quality and cheaper than competition too. I don't even shop that much, but I still maintain the membership as I come out ahead even with my occasional shopping.

The gas alone is worth the membership.

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#39

Hi, I'm the person who wrote the Twitter thread this article is based off of, so happy to answer any questions about it

Do you regret writing it in misleading clickbait style, calling it a "prison"?

[dead]

Re: The Costco of Housing is Costco? The retailer's plan to use CA housing laws

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Rental apartments are important for people who plan to live there less than 5-7 years. If all apartments were condos and there was no renting , where are people who don’t have a down payment saved supposed to live? What if they need to move to a larger place after a year or two?

That is entirely not the issue I’m raising here.

If you didn't intend to say that all rental housing is bad, you really phrased it badly.
Post reply on HN