Live data from Hacker News

Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

bbc.com

31–40 of 343 posts

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And why were those Iraqis attacking American soldiers? Perhaps because the US invaded Iraq?

You're claiming that Iraqi's were so happy under Saddam's reign, that some even fought for him?

Never underestimate people defending their home. Remember the Serbs going out with targets painted on their t-shirts when NATO (read “USA”) was bombing Belgrade? Of course that was the 90’s.

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're claiming that Iraqi's were so happy under Saddam's reign, that some even fought for him?

Never underestimate people defending their home. Remember the Serbs going out with targets painted on their t-shirts when NATO (read “USA”) was bombing Belgrade? Of course that was the 90’s.

First protest of Iraq was in 1991, but a decades long dictator ofc. has severe military superiority.

A lot of Iraqi's were a big fan of toppling Saddam.

Note : not saying it was a good idea with what we know now.

And about Serbia. The bombing from "NATO" with a focus on military targets made it possible for it's population to overthrow Milosevic by the citizens a year later.

The boots on the ground in this case were the Serbs themselves. From my POV, NATO only provided air-support for them.

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Power assymetries and parasites leaching of off that. And the anti colonial is a horrific part of that, preventing societal adaption and chanfe to be able to compete. Its so bad, colonial history goto repeat itself in africa with chinese recolonialization. Thus proofing racism a effect, not a cause.

The biggest and longest time slave traders were in the middle east. The best documented and most mentioned ones were the ones that were white.

Down voting doesn't make it untrue. Slavery exists till today and I don't see much "white" in it:

https://www.walkfree.org/global-slavery-index/

The whole white supremacy is mostly because you're free to talk about anything in the west.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-e...

Note: I'm not saying it didn't happen through history. I'm saying it's time to stop blaming "white" for everything that happens.

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#34
post #5
post #4

I'm curious about why nobody from Chiquita went to prison for financing a terrorist group. Random Afghans and Iraqis were kidnapped for Guantanamo or outright murdered for less.

[flagged]

No their CEO is Eli Black, a Rabbi. If you're going to make a connection between people's race and their behavior you should start there. /s

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#38
post #4

I'm curious about why nobody from Chiquita went to prison for financing a terrorist group. Random Afghans and Iraqis were kidnapped for Guantanamo or outright murdered for less.

I think we can all be happy with the fine that's less than a hundredth of a percent of their annual income that they'll have to pay. Justice is served.

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#39
post #26

They have been fined $38m for killing 8 people, which amounts to a tad over 1% of their 2023 revenue. I'm very happy that an example is being made of them to warn other corporations that committing murder to protect your profits may cause a slight dip in your next earnings report.

Of course it’s not nearly as much as it should be, but it is certainly a step in the right direction.

Re: Banana giant Chiquita held liable by US court for funding paramilitaries

#40
post #19

See also the Banana Massacre instigated by the United Fruit Company against plantation workers making outrageous demands like limiting the work week to 6 days. 100 years later, that company operates under the name Chiquita. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_Massacre

Also the Guatemalan coup that was heavily lobbied for by the United Fruit Company. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%2527%...

"The United Fruit Company (UFC), whose highly profitable business had been affected by the softening of exploitative labor practices in Guatemala, engaged in an influential lobbying campaign to persuade the U.S. to overthrow the Guatemalan government."

It's amazing how decades later, they heirs of United Fruit Company are still using violence as a tool for increasing profit. This is what happens when individuals are not criminally prosecuted for bad conduct. I'm sure it will happen again.

Post reply on HN