Live data from Hacker News

AI Ruined Quora

jonn.substack.com

31–40 of 100 posts

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#31
post #18

I always think people calling AI just ‘fancy autocomplete‘ haven’t really tried it yet.

But that's literally what it is. The only reason you can have dialog-like interactions with language models is because they have been trained with special "stop tokens" surrounding dialog, so the model can (generally) auto complete something that looks like a reasons, and then the inference engine can stop producing text when the model produces the stop token.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#32

Quora was already ruined and pretty much worthless for a very long time. When a query on google has quora, I hardly ever click on it as I know a) it won’t answer the question most likely b) I walk into this incredibly confusing ux experience.

I used to be an active Quora contributor and that platform is not worth saving. It kept getting worse and worse to the point where it's entire existance is just confusing.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#33
post #3

On a seperate note, why do people feel the need to exaggerate their Quora profile/education level/accomplishments? I'm not the only one who's noticed how many Quora profiles are filled with ludicrous, self-aggrandizing descriptions, right?

I'm not a 100% sure, but I've got a feeling that having a well-regarded Quora profile became a Thing in India and other parts. Then people started spamming "answers" to every question they could even tangentially produce some gibberish for. 10 years ago Quora was a place where you could get an actual expert answering questions (a thing they should've done on their own site tbh[0] with references and actual insight. N…

I read somewhere that it’s best for your blog SEO to publish there first and on medium subsequently, but couldn’t put a name to it. Thsnks!

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#34

This story is really interesting for all the not-specific-to-quora parts. It’s pretty obvious that quora has a strange culture of know-it-alls trying to show off, but this AI product makes it clear that the act of showing off is the product . The answers are garbage and they obviously don’t care. The key action for sale is not finding an answer, but writing it. What’s really interesting is that Quora product team dec…

"I would posit that there exists an opportunity to make a Twitter or Reddit clone that explicitly intermixed bots. Maybe even exclusively bots." To that I posit that Twitter and Reddit will morph into what you described. Maybe it already happened.

> … will morph into what you described. Maybe it already happened.

I can only assume that this is one of several reasons why the world’s largest social media company is on the cutting edge of LLM research.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#35

Quora was already ruined and pretty much worthless for a very long time. When a query on google has quora, I hardly ever click on it as I know a) it won’t answer the question most likely b) I walk into this incredibly confusing ux experience.

Quora was doomed from the start. When StackOverflow started the founders and the early community put a lot of thought and energy into not becoming one of the niche expert exchanges that already existed at that time. Now, Stackoverflow failed, but not by repeating the mistakes that already had been made. That's not something that could be said about Quora.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#36

Quora was already ruined and pretty much worthless for a very long time. When a query on google has quora, I hardly ever click on it as I know a) it won’t answer the question most likely b) I walk into this incredibly confusing ux experience.

Quora was doomed from the start. When StackOverflow started the founders and the early community put a lot of thought and energy into not becoming one of the niche expert exchanges that already existed at that time. Now, Stackoverflow failed, but not by repeating the mistakes that already had been made. That's not something that could be said about Quora.

Why do you say SO failed? I thought it was quite successful.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#37

Quora was already ruined and pretty much worthless for a very long time. When a query on google has quora, I hardly ever click on it as I know a) it won’t answer the question most likely b) I walk into this incredibly confusing ux experience.

Same. I really dislike how you open one question and it sort of mixes in answers to different questions. New reddit UI does something similar.

This has been one of my biggest gripes with Quora, even if user answers are useful, I’m not seeing them, which defeats the whole purpose of the site.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#38
post #18

I always think people calling AI just ‘fancy autocomplete‘ haven’t really tried it yet.

Indeed, it's actually worse. You should only use it for stuff where factuality doesn't matter. Verifying that an answer is complete and correct is more work than consulting a reliable source in the first place.

I think it's an accurate assessment and still get some use out of LLMs. Brainstorming various things, tutorials, entertainment. Straight questions with a factual answers really are a poor fit. Just yesterday GPT3.5 told me the Belgian city famous for its mustard is Dijon.

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quora was doomed from the start. When StackOverflow started the founders and the early community put a lot of thought and energy into not becoming one of the niche expert exchanges that already existed at that time. Now, Stackoverflow failed, but not by repeating the mistakes that already had been made. That's not something that could be said about Quora.

Why do you say SO failed? I thought it was quite successful.

It was quite successful.

(past tense)

Re: AI Ruined Quora

#40

I cannot remember a time when quora was not broken, so AI certainly didn't ruin it. The UI and their login popups have always been horrible enough that I try to avoid them. But in addition to that, most specific questions - the ones that would benefit the most from a nuanced human answer - get answered with generic copypasta. My impression is that Quota tried gamifying the process of answering... And they succeeded,…

You may have just joined late?

Right at the start when there was artificial signup scarcity it was fantastic. Like hn great except for questions

Post reply on HN