Live data from Hacker News

It's not what the world needs right now

thebaffler.com

31–40 of 181 posts

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#31
Most other comments so far have viewed this artist's lifestyle negatively, as he wrote that he got by via abusing various policies and tax fraud (via "[hallucinating] a DJ software skin" to claim as a business expense). But he's an interesting person for sticking to his craft for close to a decade now: he has persisted in working hard to produce artwork and submit it for exhibition.

However, to what extent is this lifestyle necessary as an artist? A common piece of advice for many artists is to consider developing a steady career independent of one's art, which lets them afford their lifestyle as an artist (such as by writing, creating artwork, or performing during the evenings and weekends). But the effectiveness of this advice must vary for the individual: it's also common for many people to drop their artwork or stop taking it seriously in favour of their paying career.

For this artist in particular, I wonder if a steady job would have been a positive or negative to his art. In this case, the income would have reduced his suffering especially as he's dealing with medical debt. It could have even granted him additional artistic freedom, as he writes about the pressures to "defect" and his acceptance of more commercial work for money. Yet at the same time, it's possible that part of the desperation is behind his drive as an artist—though it's also risky to romanticize this desperation.

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#32
post #20
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Less comments?

Fewer snarky comments like yours maybe. I believe we won’t solve humanty’s pressing problems with more of the same. We need more love and understanding for sure.

Well, your comment literally said, "less of everything"

" more love and understanding"

Was not mentioned.

So I am not sure how your first comment could help, to make the world a better place.

"we won’t solve humanty’s pressinge problems with more of the same."

And generic statements like these maybe neither.

Because when people are hungry(many are), yes they need more food. More of the same.

But your comment implies there are also maybe too many people anyway?

So rather less food and then eventually less people? But still more of love and understanding?

Or maybe it all just ain't that simple?

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#33

Imagine writing something with such honesty & the people reading don't stop to reflect on how this is just one facet of how the systems they prop up push people into operating to survive. They just judge the person, as though they live in a vacuum.

Honesty is not what the author is going for here. This is genre autofiction following a throughline of slumming, marginal artists that carries back through punk, beat, flapper, and la boheme writers.

It's entertainment, not true confession or activism, and it delights in getting under the skin of squares who can't tell.

No need to push back on the people reactively criticizing the character or writer -- that's the point.

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#35

The question I have not yet seen in the comments here is whether or not this post is real or fiction. Is it the journal of a questionable character, or a deliberate attempt to push people's buttons? And honestly, that is why I like it. I really hope it cannot be taken at face value - that would be disappointment.

[deleted]

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#36

Imagine writing something with such honesty & the people reading don't stop to reflect on how this is just one facet of how the systems they prop up push people into operating to survive. They just judge the person, as though they live in a vacuum.

Honesty is not what the author is going for here. This is genre autofiction following a throughline of slumming, marginal artists that carries back through punk, beat, flapper, and la boheme writers. It's entertainment, not true confession or activism, and it delights in getting under the skin of squares who can't tell. No need to push back on the people reactively criticizing the character or writer -- that's the po…

Deliberately making art that people think sucks seems like kind of a low bar?

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#37

> A gallerist who wants to work with me says she can’t add a white man to her roster. Pretty fucking disgusting that someone would openly say that to him.

I know a man who manages a theatre and he is pretty honest about how difficult it is to work in that market as a straight white man these days.

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#38
This was a great read and reminiscent of Kerouac (to me). It also makes me think of a life a consciously decided I didn't want after I finished art academy. I've seen others who did and got out after decades of trying and failing. I was lucky to figure out that going to art school to become an artist is a pipe dream.

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#39
It's a clever bit.

It is intellectually amusing to read, and I'm sure to write, a character that the reader hates. But the detachment becomes exhausting quick. It's a dead end; you spent all of this effort being clever, with what to show for it? After reading it, I find myself questioning which side of the joke is real and which is false, and whether I'm in the real part of the joke or the false part. Which is ultimately a fruitless exercise, since the whole thing is intentionally set up to be pointless. Got me, I guess?

I do like the visuals though.

Re: It's not what the world needs right now

#40

Imagine writing something with such honesty & the people reading don't stop to reflect on how this is just one facet of how the systems they prop up push people into operating to survive. They just judge the person, as though they live in a vacuum.

He lives this way intentionally. He could get a job as a UX designer at Staples.com whenever he wants.

There’s currently a surplus of designers with software industry experience, résumés full of business objectives achieved, and a finely honed ability to speak the soothing jargon of absolution that managers really want from UX. (“Yes, we can make users love this pop-up that you want to add. It’s just a matter of applying design.”)

Why would a corporation deliberately hire a video artist and music video director instead?

Post reply on HN