Live data from Hacker News

Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

autoweek.com

31–40 of 94 posts

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#31

In the hierarchy of road hatred, loud motorcycles are by far the most hated by all others (cars, pedestrians, cyclists, etc). Happy to hear there's no science/safety reason to encourage loud motorcycles.

I don't normally condone body shaming, but as somebody who really struggles with sudden loud noises, I will always insinuate that those with loud cars and motorbikes are compensating for something.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's one, very narrow way of viewing it. Another would be that cars lack the necessary visibility to be safe. No one in their right mind would advocate to banning cars. Instead, sensors could be employed to make up for the lack of visibility in cars. This should maybe be the topic of discussion, to introduce these types of safety sensors as essential. ABS breaks weren't the norm a few decades ago, so why not start…

I advocate for banning cars.

Thanks for considering taking away the tool I need every day to get to my job

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#34
I am keeping the stock pipe on my bike, the folks at Honda did a good job making it have a nice tone without being loud. Decent burble I can hear while riding but only just barely over the wind. I really don't need anyone else knowing what RPM I am at as long as I can hear it myself I can use it to guide my shifting. Plus the last thing I want is to wake the neighborhood when I leave early or arrive home late.

I once had a VW pickup truck, 70hp, which at one point had a broken header. I bring up the power and model just so you know how ridiculous it was to drive around at a Nascar sort of volume. I hated driving it for the week it took to get parts.

I don't mind nicely tuned exhausts, you can make a bike sound really nice compared to the near silence out of so many stock systems. Somewhere around 80-90db both sounds good and is auditory to the rider.

Tinnitus is no fun, the wind noise already aggravates mine as is. I wouldn't risk a ride on my neighbor's Harley for more than a couple minutes, must be something like 125db.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#36

In the hierarchy of road hatred, loud motorcycles are by far the most hated by all others (cars, pedestrians, cyclists, etc). Happy to hear there's no science/safety reason to encourage loud motorcycles.

I don’t know, drivers really really hate bicyclists.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for considering taking away the tool I need every day to get to my job

Thanks for assuming there are no other possible alternatives.

By car: 30 mins. Public transport: 1 hour 30 mins. I'm not wasting 2 extra hours each day.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#38
I can’t load the article because of the captcha, but based on the comments I’m assuming it’s about loud motorbike exhausts.

It’s not just bike exhausts that are loud either. Every night I hear a nearly endless stream of modified cars with pop and bang tunes. There’s not even the supposed justification that it makes you safer in a car, it’s just people doing deliberately inconsiderate things with their vehicles. It’s inflicting annoyance and misery on people for no reason but clout, and we should have less tolerance for it in society generally. It’s also the same drivers who are racing through city centres. I don’t know if they’re just racking up loads of fines and not paying them, or if they’re using swapped plates, but either way, it needs to be enforced better.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#39
post #36

In the hierarchy of road hatred, loud motorcycles are by far the most hated by all others (cars, pedestrians, cyclists, etc). Happy to hear there's no science/safety reason to encourage loud motorcycles.

I don’t know, drivers really really hate bicyclists.

In a different way. Loathe loud motorcycles and really hate bicyclists?

But you are right. I can't recall the time anyone rolled coal on motorcyclists, much less killed them trying.

Re: Do loud pipes save lives? (2021)

#40

Anecdotally, anyone who rides will you tell you this. It doesn’t matter how high your high viz vest is, or how loudly you rev your bike, someone will blindly cut you off and not realise you’re there until it’s way too late. I’m glad to see the data to back that up. Maybe now my fellow riders can agree that their motorbikes are a bit too damn loud, and tone it down.

>Maybe now my fellow riders can agree that their motorbikes are a bit too damn loud, and tone it down.

It would be awesome if the rest of us didn't have to rely on the possible good sense of a motorcyclist and, instead, noise pollution laws were strictly enforced. I highly doubt any Harley out there is even capable of operating below the legal limit in CA of 80dbA.

Post reply on HN