Live data from Hacker News

Digitopia is ruining our lives

digitopia.io

31–40 of 51 posts

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#31
Recently, as an experiment, I've begun compartmentalizing my digital tools.

I've set up different system accounts for different tasks, then I configured each account with its own privoxy proxy that blocks websites that are not related to that task. The proxies are there basically as a reminder, since a lot of these tabs tend to open without thinking of it.

So for example, on my work account, I can't use social media and news; on my social media account, I can't access github, access dashboards, or check my mail. Phone's on the work privoxy too.

The idea being that distracted context-switching, e.g. opening a hacker news tab any time there's a moment's pause in what you're doing, a moment of frustration, of boredom, any negative motion; that this is a major part of the problem.

This doesn't prevent me from checking up on social media (I'm doing it right now!), but it does mean I can't do so while supposedly working. To use social media, I need to log off the work account, closing anything I'm doing, and log into a different user. That's a lot of friction, and as a result, is something I do maybe once or twice a day for ten to fiteen minutes. I usually don't really find much to engage with and then log off.

I do find myself needing to make active choices a lot more. Like if I find I don't know what to do next, I need to decide on something. I can't just default to grabbing my phone and start cycling through the usual tabs. It's taken a while to get used to reading these moments as cues for getting off my ass and doing something, but it's also incredibly impactful.

The critical part of the regimen is that it does not have many of the drawbacks you get with going offline completely (or using a dumbphone), where you can't park your car because you need an app for that, or people try to get ahold of you and messenger isn't working on your brick.

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#32

What is wrong with the tried-and-true "alienation"? This seems like a continuation of trends that were happening long before computers came around.

Good idea! It then follows that we are looking at CAA: Computer Assisted Alienation , or maybe Optimized Alienation, or Automated...?

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#35

It's interesting that, every time an article comes up like this, I wonder why I never seem to experience the same kind of digital addiction or negative feelings that other people do - and then it turns out I'm already doing almost everything the article suggests for "unplugging". I've taken an hour long walk every single day for the past 15 years, and shower, and make sure I'm not getting overwhelmed with notificatio…

Technology is just a delivery mechanism which can be used for good or bad interactions. The problem is some technology is optimised for delivering the bad interactions because it benefits the technology vendor. Use technology that you control and decide when to interact with.

What I see is a lot of people saying on the one hand “I want my privacy and to be left alone” then hiring a vendor that is motivated to take your data and bug the shit out of you because it’s cheaper and subsidised by this poor behaviour. On top of that they then install apps which damage multiply that.

Incidentally on notifications all my kit is set on do not disturb all the time apart from alarms when I need to get up.

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#36

> Frequency: 30-60 minutes a day 30-60 minutes to take a shower?!

It’s nice to shower for a while.

But speaking of this specific line from the text, “frequency” would be “daily”, and the amount of time probably “duration” so this could perhaps be more exactly expressed as:

> Frequency and duration: 30-70 minutes a day

(Yes. Opposite order so not quite perfect either, heh.)

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#37
I generally agree with the defined problem, but when a prescription is provided then that becomes the new goal rather than the initial desired outcome (no more negative effects of digitopia). Your progress is compared against your adherence to the protocol firstly, then the initial desired outcome secondly.

With that being said, to be a bit hypocritical, and with the disclaimer that this is non-exhaustive and different things work for different people, the protocol that has worked for me is as follows:

Delete all social media

Meditate hour a day

Gym (weights, cardio) 5x a week

Good sleep

Proper diet and supplementation

Have job that pays good enough and be good at it

Live well below my means and take on no debt

I think once you remove basically everything, and you’ve listened and quieted all of your thoughts and sophisticated ape urges, you come to understand things truthfully, and wisdom + stoicism + peace naturally ensues.

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#38

> Being present - Being in the Digitopian state usually means living on autopilot. Grabbing one thing after the other, trying to get through the day, distracting yourself at any negative emotion you face. Yes, I've become aware that I am quite disconnected from "living in the moment" in a way that I was not when I was younger, a teenager. I had begun to think that it was a result of getting older, taking on more resp…

If you are going to do a context switch of this nature it’s best to do something random rather than routine. Sometimes the routine is the problem. Going for a walk every day may become a chore during winter but you feel obliged to do it because you feel like you should because of the routine you have developed. This is slave to the same thinking.

The only bit of advice I can give is spend more time with actual people in real life. That doesn’t necessarily mean close friends, just anyone you can connect with. Trade stories, ideas, experiences and importantly time with people. Be spontaneous and do things well outside your comfort zone.

Importantly though, turning off notifications and choosing when you interact with technology, not the other way round, is important.

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#39

Recently, as an experiment, I've begun compartmentalizing my digital tools. I've set up different system accounts for different tasks, then I configured each account with its own privoxy proxy that blocks websites that are not related to that task. The proxies are there basically as a reminder, since a lot of these tabs tend to open without thinking of it. So for example, on my work account, I can't use social media…

That's almost the same strategy I used to get a better work/life balance. I created a new user account on my computer and then connecting to services I used for work on it. Switching accounts is a pain (I logged off after using one), so that added enough friction for me. Similar things with social media. I allowed myself to use them, but only through a private tabs. It reduced the urge to visit them.

Re: Digitopia is ruining our lives

#40
post #8

What is wrong with the tried-and-true "alienation"? This seems like a continuation of trends that were happening long before computers came around.

What do you mean by "tried-and-true alienation"?

I mean it in the sense that Marks used it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx%27s_theory_of_alienation

I mean this not to imply a structural sense of our society, only the shock that his prediction is insanely accurate given the time and technology separating us.

Post reply on HN