Live data from Hacker News

Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

github.com

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did they imagine it would slow down scrapers/bots?

I would imagine it's for measuring engagement. They can then use the data to tailor their ad sale strategy and I imagine their content strategy.

They could turn that off for users with adblock at least. No reason to torture those who aren’t your prey – a hunters common sense.

Re: Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

#34
post #15

What is the point of sites doing this in the first place? Is it to show more ads below the content?

It may well be in some part because of what you say. But I _think_ one of the points is to allow playing video with sound. Current popular browsers only allow websites to do this after a user-initiated action on the site, such as a click. I've seen cookie bars misused to trigger autoplaying videos in the past in this way.

See, e.g., https://developer.chrome.com/blog/autoplay#new_behaviors

Re: Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

#35
post #11

Reading too much slows down scrolling and ad views, you must keep scrolling. Also, trying to have meaningful conversations with others might lead to independent ideas or actions that are out of the control of the platform, all ideas or actions must benefit only the platform and its adverisers.

are you sure you want to expand this comment? [leave it collapsed] [configure exceptions]

Would you like to know more?

[cue Starship Troopers theme]

Re: Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

#36
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I absolutely hate that on ("new") Reddit comments, because in many cases it really is something I want to see, or at least text-search through. And the weird thing is that they're trying to pinch pennies over text .

Yeah, I agree. The one that annoys me even more is github's "Load more..." in the middle of long PR/issue threads. That's really obnoxious when trying to search. And it only loads 50 comments at a time, so you have to hit it repeatedly .

To be fair, loading and rendering a huge comment thread _is_ kind of slow and a thing you don't want to do when you just want to see the latest comments at the end. But there'd be little against a second button that just loads everything, potentially at the top of the page for searchers like you.

Re: Expand Everything: Userscript to click "show more" links to expand all the text

#37

Reading too much slows down scrolling and ad views, you must keep scrolling. Also, trying to have meaningful conversations with others might lead to independent ideas or actions that are out of the control of the platform, all ideas or actions must benefit only the platform and its adverisers.

Yeah, I get your point. However I also think [see more]

I find it quite annoying that [top of full article on new page instead of the same position of this link]
Post reply on HN