Live data from Hacker News

Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

news.ycombinator.com

31–39 of 39 posts

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#31
post #18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you work for Airbnb?

I operate vacation rentals and my family makes part of our living through Airbnb, and thus have an interest in their continued growth and success as a company.

Would you mind dropping me a note? I'd like to ask you for a bit of advice, but no contact info in your profile. My profile here says how to email me (HN nick, on Google's system).

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#32
post #29
post #26

I think this is likely an automatic ban for an unusual non-dictionary word/phrase, probably just another automatic tool in their arsenal against spammers. I don't think Craigslist has it in for AirBNB specifically.

I post ads every single day of the week. This is the first occurrence of the term being blocked.

Yeah, it takes a LOT of posts with that unusual word to initiate a permablock of the whole word. Before that, it just counts against your dupe score, I think.

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#35

Its too bad that nobody has figured out how to move onto a better version of Craigslist. Their real estate listings in particular are a major source of pain for New Yorkers, and they even charge for postings there. Craigslist's lack of any customer support opens a black hole for any account issues you may be having.

People like you contribute to the problem.

Your company, Suitey, spams the hell out of craigslist.

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#36
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah it's funny the expectations people have of long running commercial services like Craigslist. Craigslist is not a public utility.

Agreed; but listings do often link out to other external sites. CraigsList seems to draw the line between a property management company and somebody like AirBNB.

You're generally prohibited from putting links in ads at all, outside of jobs and maybe a couple other categories.

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#37
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> These guys are doing a disservice to the American public. This comment blows my mind. How quickly we take things for granted is astounding. CL is a largely FREE site – I for one have sold around $1k of stuff I didn't want on there in the last decade or so – not much, but I paid exactly $0 for that. Try that with eBay or, even better, your local newspaper classifieds. The entitlement that lurks behind comments like…

Keep in mind this was a rant. Craigslist is awesome in many ways and has provided tremendous value over the years. All I am saying is their stubbornness to not improve has left a lot of value on the table. If someone else, maybe more capitalistic, was running craigslist we would probably be benefiting from it more at this point. Their monopoly of the local marketplace allows them to be complacent. The fact that they…

Why aren't you exploiting the market failure you see? Could it be that you're overestimating the amount of "value" left on the table by disallowing users to run riot over the site?

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#38

I'm guessing they got blocked because of the automated "Post to Craigslist" feature on AirBnb that pushes an AirBnb user through various screens on Craigslist, filling in information automatically, and all the user has to do is hit "Submit" at the end. CL is openly against anything that isn't a human individual expressing their energy by posting ads to another human individual via manually entering text into a mid-90…

It's not about capitalism, it's about the tragedy of the commons. Spend some time in the Craigslist Flagging Forum and see what kind of garbage people are trying to post. Craigslist's persistent value to their users is precisely a function of its self-imposed limitations.

Re: Craigslist blocking Airbnb.com

#39
post #34

Ha. I see they've gotten around it temporarily by changing the link to airbedandbreakfast.com, as in this ad: http://newyork.craigslist.org/mnh/vac/2983382098.html

Ban evasion is never a good strategy, and it reflects poorly on AirBnB that they would start adopting spammer tactics.
Post reply on HN