Live data from Hacker News

How to Choose Cookware (2014)

centurylife.org

31–40 of 68 posts

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#31

I don't understand why the author dismisses carbon steel and cast iron pans. They're my favorite. They last forever and cook great. Go into any restaurant and you'll see mostly cheap, carbon steel pans.

The only reason people prefer cast iron is an affectation for "old school" things. There is no practical, objective reason to use them over stainless steel. Advocates seem to enjoy the new hobby of cookware maintenance. Similar to how to some Reddit guys are really into shaving with straight razors as a hobby, when it performs worse than a Mach 3.

I have a well-seasoned Lodge cast iron pan, and a 5-ply All-Clad pan. Despite the fact that Lodge is in no way a high-end cookware brand, I can consistently get a perfect sear without sticking in it. The All-Clad is hit or miss.

Maybe I’m just not used to it and need to adjust something, but the cast iron at this point is dead easy to use.

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#32

I don't understand why the author dismisses carbon steel and cast iron pans. They're my favorite. They last forever and cook great. Go into any restaurant and you'll see mostly cheap, carbon steel pans.

I love my cast iron pan. Had it about 15 years. It cost maybe £15. Didn’t do anything special with it at the beginning. Just used it. Basically zero maintenance. I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt.

> Basically zero maintenance.

> I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt.

That sounds like a bit > zero maintenance, relative to other types that you can either just soak with water or stick in the dishwasher.

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#33
This is good as a survey, but can be easily simplified. 1) Get a duxtop induction portable burner. Around $100-$120. 2) Get a flat bottomed carbon steel wok ($40-$50) 3) Get a carbon steel 8" and 10" frying pan $20 & $30. 4) Get some good sauce pans (Like about $34 Cuisinart), and stock pot

No cast iron - it just takes too long to heat and to cool.

That is really all. Nothing fancy. Turn on the duxtop, it gets hot. To the same temp each time. Turn it off. There is no heat. If you use carbon steel the cooking stops almost immediately.

The need for expensive, fancy pans goes away because the heat is so consistent, reliable and fast. I have tried many ways to stir fry with both gas and electric and they just can't do it. Stir frying with an induction burner and carbon steel wok is a breeze and fun and just works.

As for non-stick. Want to cook eggs that don't stick? Heat the carbon steel until it just starts to smoke. Then add oil and let it smoke a little for 10 or 15 seconds. Done. Add the eggs, no stick.

If you have to cook for twenty people a single duxtop will not work, but then, just get a second one. In my experience that is all there is to it.

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#34

This is good as a survey, but can be easily simplified. 1) Get a duxtop induction portable burner. Around $100-$120. 2) Get a flat bottomed carbon steel wok ($40-$50) 3) Get a carbon steel 8" and 10" frying pan $20 & $30. 4) Get some good sauce pans (Like about $34 Cuisinart), and stock pot No cast iron - it just takes too long to heat and to cool. That is really all. Nothing fancy. Turn on the duxtop, it gets hot. T…

[deleted]

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love my cast iron pan. Had it about 15 years. It cost maybe £15. Didn’t do anything special with it at the beginning. Just used it. Basically zero maintenance. I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt.

> Basically zero maintenance. > I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt. That sounds like a bit > zero maintenance, relative to other types that you can either just soak with water or stick in the dishwasher.

No, it’s just quick cleaning, not maintenance. Literally 30 seconds.

I meant no rituals around being careful not to remove “layers”, an original sealing process or other nonsense

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#36
post #11
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People always complain about stainless steel when they come to my house and that's what I usually give them as that is the one I'm least worried about them damaging. I just don't think normies are interested in something which requires technique and understanding. Stainless steel requires some level of temperature control.

> People always complain about stainless steel when they come to my house Tough audience. Of all the people who have ever come to my house none has ever had a thing to say about cookware.

I think gp like to talk about their kitchen equipement to houseguests based on the comment "I just don't think normies are interested.." :D

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#37
It's Sunday night and I dont want to write a HN reply that has some ulterior business motive. I wanna share how I make eggs and maybe read a reply that gets me to improve.

1) Get some flakey oven biscuits-from-a-tube or thick sliced baguette and have them toasted, buttery, and ready on a plate for just before your eggs wrap up. After making it three times it becomes about obvious how to time these.

2) Get one of those infrared temperature thermometers you can aim down into your pots and pans. I get a pot just smaller than a pyrex bowl and boil water just beneath the bowl, a double boiler. Wait for the water to boil.

3) Toss some eggs (6 eggs is a nice breakfast for two with the biscuits) into the bowl. With a spatula, keep stirring the eggs while you monitor the temperature. Try to keep the temperature near the bottom of the glass around 70C, 160F or so. But keep the eggs constantly stirring. Literally dont put the spatula down once the eggs are in.

4) It can take like 10 minutes, but the eggs will start to thicken; if you're stirring them enough, they will be a homogenous, pleasant orange color. As they start to move beyond paint consistency, they will start to rapidly approach their end of cooking. When they just start to really thicken up, take the bowl out of the pot using a mitten. Bring the bowl to the plates with the biscuits, and put them on the plate.

There is no cheese, no butter required for the eggs. Some salt is nice. I've gotten a lot of compliments for these eggs; this recipe is one of the most common egg recipes out there and I dont know the name for it. My wife calls them 'Frenchy Eggs', I believe because of a technique origin I don't know. A rasher of bacon or ham is a lovely complement but it will not be the star compared to the eggs themselves.

You can spend the rest of the day washing that bowl with a scouring pad.

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#38
I was surprised how fast this article dismissed carbon steel. Carbon steel is my default pan. It’s lighter than cast iron and heats up faster. It’s also not really any heavier than stainless. Plus most the time I just need to gently wipe them clean and then a light coat of oil before I hang them up.

Most my by pans are De Buyer carbon steel. I do have some stainless steel pots and pans for when I need them. A couple cast iron pieces mostly use my Dutch oven.

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#39
post #28

Non-stick pans are massively overrated. For starters most foods don't stick much - it's mostly eggs that are a problem - and only then if your pan isn't preheated. For that small benefit, non-stick pans have become almost the default. They last a couple of years depending on care which means that your cookware is now a consumable as well was difficult to recycle. A decent stainless steel pan costs about twice what a…

> It can also go in the dishwasher Why would you do such a thing? It breaks my frying pan heart. Be gentle, clean with oil, wipe off excess. It will love you back.

because its stainless steel, it'll be fine

Re: How to Choose Cookware (2014)

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love my cast iron pan. Had it about 15 years. It cost maybe £15. Didn’t do anything special with it at the beginning. Just used it. Basically zero maintenance. I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt.

> Basically zero maintenance. > I just wash it with a wire brush and some salt. That sounds like a bit > zero maintenance, relative to other types that you can either just soak with water or stick in the dishwasher.

Cast iron does wash differently from other things, but in my experience it's less work. Most of my cooking is on cast iron, and when I'm done I rinse it under the tap, rubbing a bit with a scrubber if food is stuck to it. I don't use salt. Then I put it back on the stove for a minute until it's dry. It takes me about 30s to clean a pot, less time than something I need to rinse-soap-rinse, and I end up with a clean pot on my stove ready for the next use.

Our stove almost always has a 10" dutch oven, 6" pan, and 10" pan sitting on it, ready to use.

Post reply on HN