Live data from Hacker News

Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

cnn.com

31–40 of 75 posts

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#31

I understand that streaming is a great option but what about high quality? I buy Blu-rays of media where quality is a high point of the experience. Things like Pixar films, traditional animation, films with extraordinary visuals (e.g. LoTR). Are there full-quality digital/downloadable options that I'm not aware of?

I think a lot of streaming services offer some sort of 4K upgrade pricing. [0] Doesn't seem like the requirements for netflix are even that demanding, minimum 15mbps is at least a common internet speed where I'm from. [0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444

The requirements are so low because the bitrate is so low. 4k off an internet stream doesn’t compare to off the disc.

If you want DolbyVision, HDR, highest resolution and bitrate, physical media is still the only option that I’m aware of. Bummed about this happening because when I’ve tried ordering Bluray from Amazon, the discs sometimes show up loose in the cases and scratched up.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#32

I understand that streaming is a great option but what about high quality? I buy Blu-rays of media where quality is a high point of the experience. Things like Pixar films, traditional animation, films with extraordinary visuals (e.g. LoTR). Are there full-quality digital/downloadable options that I'm not aware of?

I think a lot of streaming services offer some sort of 4K upgrade pricing. [0] Doesn't seem like the requirements for netflix are even that demanding, minimum 15mbps is at least a common internet speed where I'm from. [0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444

4k content from Netflix does not look as good as 4k content from Blu-ray. Especially for dark scenes, Netflix's stream is full of decompression artifacts making everything grey and blotchy.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#33

I understand that streaming is a great option but what about high quality? I buy Blu-rays of media where quality is a high point of the experience. Things like Pixar films, traditional animation, films with extraordinary visuals (e.g. LoTR). Are there full-quality digital/downloadable options that I'm not aware of?

Apple will sell you 4K downloads through iTunes. IME they're pretty good about getting you on to the latest/highest quality version of something if there is ever an upscaled edition released.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#34
post #30

Oddly enough my college-aged daughter just asked if we had an extra dvd player laying around, and if not she might get one/ask for one for Christmas. I think she's preparing for when she gets locked out of all of the family's streaming services, or they all go ad-supported.

Have any streaming services gone ad-supported beyond introducing lower cost tiers as an alternative to existing premium subscriptions without ads?

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#35

I understand that streaming is a great option but what about high quality? I buy Blu-rays of media where quality is a high point of the experience. Things like Pixar films, traditional animation, films with extraordinary visuals (e.g. LoTR). Are there full-quality digital/downloadable options that I'm not aware of?

I think a lot of streaming services offer some sort of 4K upgrade pricing. [0] Doesn't seem like the requirements for netflix are even that demanding, minimum 15mbps is at least a common internet speed where I'm from. [0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444

By comparison Blueray can do 92 mbps on 50GByte disks or 144 mbps on 100GByte disks.

I realize different encoding can be more efficient but Netflix etc still just looks worse.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#36
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think a lot of streaming services offer some sort of 4K upgrade pricing. [0] Doesn't seem like the requirements for netflix are even that demanding, minimum 15mbps is at least a common internet speed where I'm from. [0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444

Netflix 4k is laughably bad in comparison to Blu-ray 4k. Blu-Ray 4k has about 10x higher bitrate.

Haha yeah that's possible, I don't even own a 4K TV at the moment, so I'm out of the loop here. I guess in the exact terms of how many lit-up pixels you get per second, it's the same. 15mbps sounds like some serious compression though I bet.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#37

I understand that streaming is a great option but what about high quality? I buy Blu-rays of media where quality is a high point of the experience. Things like Pixar films, traditional animation, films with extraordinary visuals (e.g. LoTR). Are there full-quality digital/downloadable options that I'm not aware of?

I think a lot of streaming services offer some sort of 4K upgrade pricing. [0] Doesn't seem like the requirements for netflix are even that demanding, minimum 15mbps is at least a common internet speed where I'm from. [0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444

[deleted]

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#38
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You will still be able to buy Blu-rays, just not from Best Buy

It probably marks the beginning of the end for the medium though

Steam was the beginning of the end for physical media, it got the ball rolling on normalizing for a whole generation the lack of media ownership.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#39
post #30

Oddly enough my college-aged daughter just asked if we had an extra dvd player laying around, and if not she might get one/ask for one for Christmas. I think she's preparing for when she gets locked out of all of the family's streaming services, or they all go ad-supported.

Have any streaming services gone ad-supported beyond introducing lower cost tiers as an alternative to existing premium subscriptions without ads?

Depends on your definition of ad. Netflix seems to be doing a lot of product placement.

Re: Best Buy stores to stop selling DVDs, Blu-ray in 2024

#40
I am back at DVD. Stuff I like isn’t or not anymore streamed, only available via DVD.

DVD however is annoying. Waiting for the Menu, FBI warning - everything you don’t need nor want as paying customer.

So I am considering doing what needs to be done: NAT sever with ripped DVDs. Local streaming. ;)

Post reply on HN