Live data from Hacker News

Saint Helena Island Communications

sainthelenaisland.info

31–40 of 149 posts

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a meme-like website that demos this very concept. Then there's a v2.0 or some ++ type versioning where they use very minimal CSS to actually improve the readability. I'm a fan of the use of the minimal CSS to add margins and widths as it improves readability for me. Searching for it with only the vagueness of what I can think of right now returns nothing useful, and that's with not using Google. Maybe my vagu…

The original (I think): https://motherfuckingwebsite.com/ First improvement: http://bettermotherfuckingwebsite.com/ Later iterations: https://thebestmotherfucking.website/ https://perfectmotherfuckingwebsite.com/

yup, this is it. thanks for being the collective memory

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#33
post #17
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why bother with Starlink if the fiberoptic subsea cable is live now?

It's not rolled out yet: http://sainthelenaisland.info/communications.htm#maestrotech...

> Due to delays in finalising designs for the new network, it is now accepted that it will not be completed by January 2024

If they haven't finalized the design, I'd say they've got a ways to go.

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if other countries will (or have) ban Starlink for censorship reasons. Or frankly, lack of censorship control. So much of our governance, if not all, is based on geographic sovereignty, and satellites can supersede that. I hope we finally get more global governance to deal with more and more global issues.

I remember reading that Starlink routes traffic via base stations in the subscriber’s own country, in order not to anger regulators. If you think about it it makes sense; otherwise governments could just ban the sale of Starlink equipment for violating the law.

Frankly it would be easier to enforce at the payments layer. Governments have a lot greater control over their financial system than the movement of physical goods (see war on drugs where drugs move freely despite massive interdiction efforts but money is done through currency as integrated financial products are easily monitored and controlled)

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#35

I (sorta) know the author of a self-published book, Finding Napoleon which I think covers his time on St. Helena. It's funny that they don't much mention the main reason anyone's heard of it.

Anyone's heard of what? St Helena? I think it is pretty well known in its own right so I don't see reason for a site about telecoms on the island to reference someone who was on the island hundreds of years ago ?

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mean the epic steps?

I did a find on "Napoleon." what did I miss?

Why would the communications page of their site mention him? He's mentioned on other pages if you're curious enough to explore the site, though.

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#37

> It has come to the attention of the St Helena Government that members of the public may have acquired, imported and be currently using terminals, such as Starlink, for the purposes of internet connectivity. Using such terminals is in contravention of the exclusivity of current telecommunications licencing arrangements made under section 3(4) of the Telecommunications Ordinance 1989. From 1 November 2023 anyone usin…

Does a monopoly make sense here? Pre starlink, there was probably a huge cost to bring internet to the island, and those doing so wanted to have some form of protection in order to confidently invest the capital to do so.

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if other countries will (or have) ban Starlink for censorship reasons. Or frankly, lack of censorship control. So much of our governance, if not all, is based on geographic sovereignty, and satellites can supersede that. I hope we finally get more global governance to deal with more and more global issues.

I remember reading that Starlink routes traffic via base stations in the subscriber’s own country, in order not to anger regulators. If you think about it it makes sense; otherwise governments could just ban the sale of Starlink equipment for violating the law.

Telcos do pretty much the same -- US SIMs in China receive different Great Firewall treatment than Chinese SIMs, and I've seen some Chinese SIMs / phones on some cell networks in the US get routed back through the Great Firewall. Which is IMO pretty disgusting on the part of the US telcos, but sorta functionally the same as what you say Starlink does.

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if other countries will (or have) ban Starlink for censorship reasons. Or frankly, lack of censorship control. So much of our governance, if not all, is based on geographic sovereignty, and satellites can supersede that. I hope we finally get more global governance to deal with more and more global issues.

I remember reading that Starlink routes traffic via base stations in the subscriber’s own country, in order not to anger regulators. If you think about it it makes sense; otherwise governments could just ban the sale of Starlink equipment for violating the law.

Seems unlikely that Starlink would put a base station on Saint Helena just to be able to serve some percentage of ~4000 population. Most likely the base station is somewhere else.

Re: Saint Helena Island Communications

#40
post #12

> It has come to the attention of the St Helena Government that members of the public may have acquired, imported and be currently using terminals, such as Starlink, for the purposes of internet connectivity. Using such terminals is in contravention of the exclusivity of current telecommunications licencing arrangements made under section 3(4) of the Telecommunications Ordinance 1989. From 1 November 2023 anyone usin…

Why bother with Starlink if the fiberoptic subsea cable is live now?

Redundancy is also nice – given how remote Saint Helena is, I could imagine repairs taking quite some time.
Post reply on HN