Live data from Hacker News

What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

vishnumenon.com

31–40 of 219 posts

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#31
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2037 maybe, but four years isn't very long.

Four years is an eternity in software, especially now that we can have LLMs write the first draft. Transformers were only invented six years ago after all. Some people are even very optimistically projecting that we'll reach the singularity in the next three.

Feels a bit like dot.com

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#33
post #25

> Even if an LLM could provide me with a recipe that perfectly suits what I’m looking for, I wouldn’t want to give up the experience of using a recipe search engine and browsing through a large collection of recipes. Even if an LLM could provide me with restaurant recommendations based on my preferences, I’d still seek out a map-based UX for exploring the variety present in my vicinity. The desire to replace all UX w…

> If business software (sheets, Photoshop, CAD etc.) can be sped up with chat input, it will be, and people will be expected to use the quickest UI. I have a hard time seeing chat input become the primary UI for that class of applications, unless you can delegate complete tasks to it. As an analogy, for driving a car, I can see voice commands replacing the steering wheel if we reach full self-driving capabilities, bu…

I think the biggest change will be users will increase my parents don't know how to use Photoshop are not tech inclined they won't be touching up photos of their grand child. But give them an option of just asking the app to do something and they will as the learning curve goes down dramatically

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#34
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2037 maybe, but four years isn't very long.

Four years is an eternity in software, especially now that we can have LLMs write the first draft. Transformers were only invented six years ago after all. Some people are even very optimistically projecting that we'll reach the singularity in the next three.

Making comfortable and capable mixed reality glasses common is not primarily a software problem. In fact, I'd say the challenges are almost entirely unrelated to software, though there probably would be a need for a richer software ecosystem designed for mixed reality for them to really take off.

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#37
I agree with the author that chat interfaces for LLMs can be suboptimal. A chat could require redundancies that is not required to perform a task and it imposes a linear flow of information. It is hard to have branching behaviour in a chat. I have been experimenting with using a different kind of a UI to overcome these limitations: https://www.heuristi.ca/

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#38
> I don’t believe that natural language is an adequate medium for conveying instructions with the precision required for many applications.

Not clear to me if the author actually uses LLMs to do meaningful work, or is speculating about how they might be used.

I've written about 2500 lines of F# for the first time in the past 1.5 weeks using ChatGPT-4 to guide me. It has been an constant back and forth, iterative process. My decades of development experience factored in heavily to guide the process. I would've have been at maybe a quarter the progress without ChatGPT, or given up entirely on F# as my language.

I don't think that iterative aspect will be eliminated any time soon for AI-supported complex, creative processes. It's no different from tweaking inputs to a Photoshop filter until your experienced brain decides things look right.

To that end you need to know roughly what looks "right" before you use an LLM. This will all become second nature to the average developer in the next 5-10 years.

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#39
post #13

Ok. I appreciate they didn't use Medium as a blog post. There's a lot of good engineering knowledge currently locked behind the Medium "sign in" interface. It's dumb and stupid. But just to voice an opinion, please kill the lengthy paragraph levels of fluff in blog posts. I don't want to say my opinion is influenced by shitty blog recipes and research papers, but it is. So stop it. Just say what you need to say in bu…

While I agree some longform articles could use a bulleted summary, I think the act of blog-writing is as much an exercise of the writer coming to terms with the subject as us enjoying the piece. Abridging an idea comes easier after exploring its breadth and width, and I am supportive of anyone who tries it out in the open.

I agree with this and often even find myself leaving drafts around to read, re-read, and edit as I flesh out the ideas and thoughts in my own brain.

Writing in long form is its own process of mental synthesis.

Re: What will LLM-powered software look like in the medium-term future?

#40
My prediction: knowledge will start to be reformatted into an LLM directly and knowledge providers will stop publishing it otherwise. Thus the chat interface will both improve and protect knowledge access once the traditional formats are not published anymore.

This will come together with the downfall of search, a prime driver why so much knowledge was published on the web. Search will start to drown in an explosion of generated AI content, and the case to publish your knowledge for the sake of SEO marketing will diminish.

Post reply on HN