Live data from Hacker News

FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

news.ycombinator.com

31–35 of 35 posts

Re: FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

#31
post #4

Good. This is exactly what people who disable watch history wants.

Doubtful. They want privacy. It doesn't equate to wanting no recommendations.

The android YouTube App on my Pico projector doesn't need a. Login to watch my history and make recommendations.

The most likely privacy invasion is like the most likely assailant in violence: people you know.

Re: FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

#32
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How so? I don’t enable watch history but would still like to see recommendations. Could be based on geography, or overall trends, or time of day. Or whatever. Also, I find it funny to think Google isn’t tracking my watch history even if they aren’t showing it back to me. So why not try to have a positive user behavior. I don’t like Google’s attitude of “we’re going to purposely make our product shitty unless you enab…

> I don’t enable watch history but would still like to see recommendations. Could be based on geography, or overall trends, or time of day. The Explore tab has "Trending, Music, Gaming, News, Sports". And each of those has more specific sub-sections.

For happier customers, they should pick one of those and show it by default.

Re: FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

#33

You guys use the home screen? It's just ads. Watch the subscription feed.

My subscription feed is filled with things that are completely irrelevant because it doesn't adapt to my interests. I guess I could prune my subscriptions but why would I when the home screen works so much better? Also if you only watch people you're already subscribed to it will be hard to find new things. I don't know what makes you say the home screen is "just ads" because that's definitely not true

It's just ads because YouTube serves you think most clickbaity thing that will keep your eyeballs on screen (for the ads). Homepage doesn't care about discovery at all that's just a side effect.

I think maybe you should stop subscribing to channels you don't like?

Re: FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

#34
post #2

They wrote a blog post about this change last week as if it was a good thing. It's not a good thing: "you’ll be able to see the search bar and the left-hand guide menu, with no feed of recommended videos thus allowing you to more easily search, browse subscribed channels and explore Topic tabs instead." I'm still not enabling my watch history.

They’re deliberately being a petty asshole about it (that part isn’t good) but the end result is actually probably better for your brain so I’m fine with the pettiness.

Re: FYI YouTube home screen does not show any videos if watch history is off

#35
post #8
post #5

Youtube needs a refresh suggestions button

“I’m feeling lucky” and “Just show me a random video” would be fun. Also just having weird stuff like “show me a video that most closely matches this color scheme” or “find me the antipode of this video”

Look for an app called "Neverthink". It's on Apple-TV too.
Post reply on HN