Live data from Hacker News

The downfall of National Geographic

jjpryor.substack.com

31–40 of 121 posts

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#31
post #15

I lost interest in NG since they dumbed content down and concentrated on political correctness and being on the "right" side of the political spectrum instead of providing interesting, deeply researched and meticulously planned articles and caring more for the scientific truth instead of the political truth.

[flagged]

Trying really hard to not be mean/offensive really is the same thing as putting people in camps for criticizing those in power.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#32
post #15

I lost interest in NG since they dumbed content down and concentrated on political correctness and being on the "right" side of the political spectrum instead of providing interesting, deeply researched and meticulously planned articles and caring more for the scientific truth instead of the political truth.

[flagged]

Stop with this garbage already.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#33

This isnt exclusive to NG. This phenomena exists for seemingly every IP. I'll give video games as an example because it seems so clear cut and many people experienced this cycle already. >A company starts out relatively small and is able to turn a profit or attract investment. They continue to be relatively unknown. >The company releases their first breakout hit (Halo, Morrowind or Oblivion, Zelda OOT). The employees…

Zelda's not the best example of this-- their mainline releases are fantastic as ever.

You might be falling into the

>The IP fans continue to buy each product. Some will be optimistic, some will be pessimistic, doesnt matter, they will continue to buy.

Source: I'm one of those OOT/MM fans. But admittedly so, the 2D Zelda's were great. I imagine these were different teams that peaked at different times. Windwaker was most definitely a game 3 for me, with TP being a game 4, with all the signs of a game 4. Now we are getting average-mediocre open world games with Zelda IP skinned on them. Its hard to say BOTW is anything like Majoras mask who had somewhere between 7-10x more unique enemy types. This one and Blizzard(Starcraft/warcraft/diablo) hurts the most in retrospect.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#34
post #16

Nearly every single newspaper and magazine company has the exact same revenue and subscriber growth chart over the last 20 years. Its a roughly 30-degree angle down and to the right, from a high around 2000 to todays near bankrupcy across the board. Everybody got laid off, everything is produced by freelancers hitting wordcount and postcount metrics by the hour. There's nothing special about NatGeo here, Time, Newswe…

> It makes sense that often the old things have to die for the new things to truly take over the ecological niche.

The real problem is when the old things die and nothing has really filled their niche. NG is a good example, I think.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#35
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Zelda's not the best example of this-- their mainline releases are fantastic as ever.

Nintendo was also already a corporate behemoth by the time OoT came out.

That is the larger organization, there are microcosms inside each company.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#36

Do you see more of this collapse of written media houses? With willingness to pay for media at an all time low + cost of production of writing going to near zero, the demise of online media publications is near inevitable. Will we see a resurgence of a new form of personalized research replacing this void for which folks will be willing to pay for? Is there a need for intermediaries in the space? Does direct publishi…

Maybe high-quality physical print that looks good on a bookshelf. Similar to how vinyl records are thriving in the streaming music era

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They dumbed down long before that, that was just when you noticed. It was that success in the 80s that largely killed them, because they realized that their brand pushed product. The business turned to commercial branding or retail stores and selling random stuff, culminating in becoming one of the random logos on a bland Korean fashion brand. My guess is that many who were turned off because they "went woke" loved i…

> There's still plenty of room for high-quality writing about the world and its inhabitants; Where can this be found?

I don't know of a single place where you can consistently can find "high-quality writing about the world and its inhabitants" as on former NG. There are quality articles but they are scattered against the vast deserts of the Internet.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#39
post #8

"...And at the same time, the group that started the magazine, the National Geographic Society, which used to run on a budget of millions, now has 1.6 billion dollars in its piggy bank." What on earth are they doing as a non profit to justify keeping that stash safe from taxation?

> What on earth are they doing as a non profit to justify keeping that stash safe from taxation?

They are stashing 1.6 billion bucks is what they're doing. Regardless of how pure the original motives may be for any foundation or non-profit, if they get enough money in them they will be taken over by the soul-less financiers.

Re: The downfall of National Geographic

#40
post #8

"...And at the same time, the group that started the magazine, the National Geographic Society, which used to run on a budget of millions, now has 1.6 billion dollars in its piggy bank." What on earth are they doing as a non profit to justify keeping that stash safe from taxation?

> What on earth are they doing as a non profit to justify keeping that stash safe from taxation? They are stashing 1.6 billion bucks is what they're doing. Regardless of how pure the original motives may be for any foundation or non-profit, if they get enough money in them they will be taken over by the soul-less financiers.

[dead]
Post reply on HN