Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 97 posts

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which was earned via moderation and 3rd party apps

time will show if old mods and 3p apps are that critical, since both are removed now.

time already shew, since the subreddits exist as they are now

obviously taking what they built and saying "I built this" wouldn't show anything but spez's pettiness

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#32
post #15
post #6

The only real end to this is reddit taking ownership over moderation, and hiring paid moderators for all the subreddits, turning off user created subreddits. Maybe it'll also mean turning off user generated content too, and only have admin made posts, the same as Digg did. They could hire the power-users to keep making the relevant posts. People you don't have on contract are a liability

They don't need users to generate content anymore. They have LLMs trained to strategically produce the best comments.

I wonder how long it would take to notice.

Shadowban all users. Respond to their comments and posts with AI generated responses only visible to the poster. Redditors famously don't want others to know their handle so they won't share it around. You could only tell from a signed out device reading something you commented in.

Flood the site with generated posts and 'engagement' that is all ad friendly. Turn the whole place into Weenie Hut Jr.

Do this pre IPO then bail forever.

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#33
post #14
post #6

The only real end to this is reddit taking ownership over moderation, and hiring paid moderators for all the subreddits, turning off user created subreddits. Maybe it'll also mean turning off user generated content too, and only have admin made posts, the same as Digg did. They could hire the power-users to keep making the relevant posts. People you don't have on contract are a liability

> The only real end to this is reddit taking ownership over moderation, and hiring paid moderators for all the subreddits, turning off user created subreddits. how so? there are more than enough moderators left who have no issue with reddit's current behaviour and will continue modding for free.

there are more than enough sex offenders willing to step up and replace daycare employees, that doesn't mean it's a good idea

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#34

Reddit's explanation (from an admin account, /u/ModCodeofConduct) is that 'encouraging the submission of sexually explicit (18+) content in previously safe-for-work spaces' counts as 'engaging in malicious conduct' that breaks the Moderator Code of Conduct. https://twitter.com/aaronp613/status/1671298446974656514 To me it doesn't seem like they actually violated any Reddit policy or code of conduct, particularly beca…

Given the mod team encouraged people to upload pictures of fruit and vegetables that were suggestive of butts and dicks and vulvas and such...

...no, it's clearly about someone at reddit raging out of control and grasping at straws to justify banhammering mods in a desperate attempt to save a ship that has split in two, is on fire, leaking radioactive waste, while sharks circle.

I've seen this happen on mailing lists and discussion boards where an admin/mod throws a major wobbly and just starts banning people like crazy for the slightest infractions to scare everyone else into "behaving." That's about when quietly someone who is respected pools together every email they can get their hands on and invites everyone to mailing list run elsewhere.

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#35
post #6

The only real end to this is reddit taking ownership over moderation, and hiring paid moderators for all the subreddits, turning off user created subreddits. Maybe it'll also mean turning off user generated content too, and only have admin made posts, the same as Digg did. They could hire the power-users to keep making the relevant posts. People you don't have on contract are a liability

There's simply no way for that to be economically viable.

That's the whole point of reddit; for various reasons they convinced people to give them fuckloads of free labor.

Reddit brilliantly acted like "king" giving fiefdoms out to mods and pretending like it was "theirs." "Here, dear mod! Here is some internet land to rule mostly as you see fit."

Well...the king demanded a huge tithe, a good portion of the lords told the king his mother was a hamster and his father smelled like elderberries....and the king is now laying down the law and making it very clear who everything actually belongs to.

The problem is: without any lords, the king has no power, because he can't possibly administer all the fiefdoms himself...and right now, a lot of the peasants really fucking hate the king, and like the lords.

Right now spez is trying to scare mods straight and reward those who toe the line by redistributing fiefdoms to them.

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

except the community voted for a new normal...

could you give a link?

No, no. If you purport to know what redditors supposedly want, you can read the OP and simply go to the listed subreddits and see the top posts for the votes/announcements.

edit: I mean let's be real, you've been panning for reddit for two weeks. You're concern trolling asking for links.

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#38
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They don't need users to generate content anymore. They have LLMs trained to strategically produce the best comments.

I wonder how long it would take to notice. Shadowban all users. Respond to their comments and posts with AI generated responses only visible to the poster. Redditors famously don't want others to know their handle so they won't share it around. You could only tell from a signed out device reading something you commented in. Flood the site with generated posts and 'engagement' that is all ad friendly. Turn the whole p…

Even when 90% of subs were down, I didn't notice much difference. I visited r/interestingAsFuck several times but it was candy. It's why I delete Reddit every now and then.

There's a lot of reposted content too. I tried to farm r/poetry to feed my LLM, but the top stuff are the same reposted poems and edgy anti-poetry. Reddit could just repost the same thing again and again.

Re: Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large Subreddits

#40
post #39

they have every right to do so and it's well needed. Few teenager thinking they are playing games just by being a mod of a commercial platform. bunch of kids.

Then the platform should have professional paid mods instead. But that would not be economically viable for Reddit. So those teenagers are subsidizing Reddit by their free time.
Post reply on HN