Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

blogs.microsoft.com

31–40 of 344 posts

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#31

My first thought is, "gross"... now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking. Could lead to a world that's even more tilted towards politics and socially engineering your way up the ladder, versus competence and skill.

That's kind of my concern as well. I feel like there is already a decline in thinking, but currently I can at least tell that it's the case.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#34
post #24

My first thought is, "gross"... now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking. Could lead to a world that's even more tilted towards politics and socially engineering your way up the ladder, versus competence and skill.

On the other hand, maybe you prefer the decisions the AI takes for them instead of what they would do by themselves.

System prompt:

>>> You're a strict yet lenient manager, you have very high expectations from your reports, while making them feel like they are part of a bigger family. every email you write should reflect this.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#36

My first thought is, "gross"... now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking. Could lead to a world that's even more tilted towards politics and socially engineering your way up the ladder, versus competence and skill.

ChatGPT opened my eyes to the fact that we already should have been wondering about it.

I tried using ChatGPT to generate answers to some requests to my team, and it created the most plausible wild goose chase answers I could ever imagine. They would be a terrible waste of time for anyone who received them.

Then I started to notice how many of the emails and requests I get are just as bad! Plausible sounding answers directing me to teams that don't exist, or telling me to read documentation that doesn't apply to the question I asked. Asking questions that seems specific but have fundamental contradictions that make them nonsense.

With people's limited knowledge and time and lack of attention and care we already live in the world of plausible bullshit hallucinated nonsense.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#37
post #22

I wonder how this will play out. Yes, it’s pretty awesome and yes, helpful. But if we extend the timeline, doesn’t this likely lead to AI-generated responses talking to AI-generated questions about AI-generated presentations?

We already have students using AI to generate answers for homework and teachers using automation to grade it. I would say we are already there.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#38

That seams to be one of the best use cases for this, provided you can run it without giving Microsoft a lot of data directly. Else this is a no-no for enterprises imo.

Enterprises that already give Microsoft a lot of data directly? Office 365 is ubiquitous in that space.

Sure, but most (if not all?) of us have language in our customer agreements that Microsoft doesn't have rights to just start browsing our OneDrive libraries and Exchange inboxes without a support contract explicitly authorizing access for support purposes. Just like, sure, I technically have access to a bunch of PHI at my workplace - but touching it without a valid reason is a one-way ticket to the unemployment line.

But unlike Microsoft's other services, AI needs data to train on - are they going to be content just sourcing this from the internet at large or have we finally hit an inflection point where they try to get business and enterprise customers to give access in exchange for these features? That's a big no-no to anyone in a field that deals with sensitive information, and in most all cases an equally big no-no to anyone in a company that wants to keep things confidential.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#39

My first thought is, "gross"... now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking. Could lead to a world that's even more tilted towards politics and socially engineering your way up the ladder, versus competence and skill.

> now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking

If my experience in engineering is anything to go by, this worry existed since the dawn of middle management. AI just makes it give good responses instead.

Post reply on HN