Live data from Hacker News

GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

github.com

31–40 of 221 posts

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#31

It managed to write, in one shot, a working λ-calculus parser, using a very specific programming style I asked it in JavaScript, and then translated it all to Python, including sarcastic, rhyming GLaDOS comments. https://twitter.com/VictorTaelin/status/1635726202231988225 It also seems to be extremely competent at writing Agda types and proofs. We need some tool that highly integrates it with entire codebases, allowi…

Yeah, its really cool how good it is. I personally am addicted to it.

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#32

GPT-4 is just really good at code. We documented some of the examples that we found were crazy amazing and worth hackernews. Including GPT-4's ability to handle bazel, kube, terraform and rust. A summary can be found on this thread: https://twitter.com/sualehasif996/status/1635755267739598848

If you know of any other cool examples or would like us to try something out and add to the repo, please let us know. If you have access, the repo should be fairly replicable.

Your example of the commenting doesn't seem like "well-commented code" to me.

Just re-stating what is in code in plain language isn't helpful and is kind of annoying to read.

Can you explain why you think it is helpful?

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#33
post #13
post #8

Well, I think I just retired. Even knowing this was coming, it's still a bit unnerving. Sad too, but it's for the best. Let the machines program the machines. Schmidhuber's Gödelmachine. The automatic scientist .

Yes, the kinds of people who would write a python program in C++ are in trouble.

Maybe it can translate python code to C++. That is interesting. I need to try that.

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#34

I'm waiting for copilot that has access to something like language server and instead of just suggesting immediate completions and using open tabs for context it can use LS to pull references for context, suggest file creation, adding code in non trivial places. Then add a chat interface on top. Suddenly I'm really 10x - I would pay hundreds of dollars per month for this if it worked well - it would let me handle at…

that's exactly what we're building with Control! https://twitter.com/sualehasif996/status/1635757961984221185

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#36
post #8

Well, I think I just retired. Even knowing this was coming, it's still a bit unnerving. Sad too, but it's for the best. Let the machines program the machines. Schmidhuber's Gödelmachine. The automatic scientist .

All this does is change how you go about getting computers to work for you. Someone off the street still needs to know how to express themselves correctly to get a result that's not crap. And they don't know what they don't know. So this thread will be filled with people freaking out about the ends of their jobs. When really it just changes how their jobs work.

The nailgun didn't retire carpenters. They just got more productive.

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#37
post #8

Well, I think I just retired. Even knowing this was coming, it's still a bit unnerving. Sad too, but it's for the best. Let the machines program the machines. Schmidhuber's Gödelmachine. The automatic scientist .

Just the opposite, this is letting me pick up more work than ever. The nature of that continues to shift as rote memorization becomes less important, but that was already the case thanks to earlier forms of code completion. It may be that breadth is becoming more valuable than depth. The engineering design process is more important than ever, along with soft skills and an eye for what kind of work matters.

I am on this side of the argument. It is letting me code better than ever before :) I have been able to pick up new languages/build systems much faster than in the past (Swift for example.)

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#38
post #14

Remember the comments about artists and creatives when DALL-E came out? I remember.

I think my barber and my plumber have safer jobs from automation than average coders.

Sigh. Time to bust out my old will code for food cardboard sign.

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#39
post #14

Remember the comments about artists and creatives when DALL-E came out? I remember.

I think my barber and my plumber have safer jobs from automation than average coders.

I think we'll all get more productive is all. There's a lot of projects that just weren't economical but now may become so.

The bigger disruption will occur when Google, Facebook, Twitter, Reddit etc become useless from all the AI spam that's sure to overwhelm it all.

Re: GPT-4 is phenomenal at Code

#40

> is phenomenal at Code Can it - attend bullshit meetings - lick my manager's boot - tell them that their ideas are good but in the masochistic, self-deprecating way they like to hear it from me in Not yet? Darn it, guess my job is safe for now.

It can. The only difficult part of all that is wiring up the integrations and I/O.
Post reply on HN