Live data from Hacker News

Come Break My Compiler

bellmar.medium.com

31–33 of 33 posts

Re: Come Break My Compiler

#31

> No “real programmers” write code in Assembly. This means the opposite of what she means, which is > No, “real programmers” write code in Assembly. because of the missing comma. Insisting on good spelling and grammar is not about being annoying, it's about not accidentally writing the opposite of what you want to convey :(

> Insisting on good spelling and grammar is not about being annoying, it's about not accidentally writing the opposite of what you want to convey :( True, but in this case, you were able to infer the intended meaning from context, which is what reading is: interpreting text, which involves assigning meanings to symbols and resolving ambiguities to render the whole as intelligible as possible. Since nothing can be dra…

> True, but in this case, you were able to infer the intended meaning from context, which is what reading is: interpreting text, which involves assigning meanings to symbols and resolving ambiguities to render the whole as intelligible as possible.

Yes, but each ambiguity in a given piece of text makes it harder to infer the intended meaning, in a way that's not linear with the number of ambiguities (or at least doesn't feel so). A missed comma here, an extra comma there, couple typos, and suddenly the text switches from understandable, if slightly tiresome to read, to entirely unintelligible sequence of glyphs that requires approaching it as a puzzle to have a chance at understanding what it says. The threshold for this switch is different for everyone, so it's in everyone's interest to keep your grammar and spelling correct.

Re: Come Break My Compiler

#32
post #9
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Amazingly, I knew exactly what she meant. It's also entirely aside from the point of the article, and either interpretation still works toward making her underlying point.

I understood the intention behind the sentence as well, after all it's a common joke. However, it also distracted me from the post, and lead me to think about spelling instead of the author's compiler... which I don't think was intended.

I respectfully disagree this is a problem for the author to fix.
Post reply on HN