Live data from Hacker News

Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

arstechnica.com

31–40 of 90 posts

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#31

Give the over promise and (way, way, waaaaay) under deliver of all his self driving bloviations there’s no way in hell I’d be down to let him implant anything in my head.

Are you quadriplegic/paraplegic? I'm sure that will influence you decision

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#32

Even DARPA dropped the idea of brain surgery and has gone back to non-invasive technology, Neuralink should do the same. (2018) > "To try and figure out how to make this technology more accessible and not require surgical placement of a metal probe into people's brains, DARPA recently launched the NExt-Generation Nonsurgical Neurotechnology (N3) program. The plan is to make a device with similar capabilities, but it'…

Such devices are a dead end, imo. I think the next generation of BMI will likely be something you can put on your head like old time headphones with some being even less invasive than that maybe as mere 'pebbles' you just put on your temples or where ever else is potentially optimal for interacting with the human brain.

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#33

Too much hate here. It's surprising how quicly people jumped from "Elon is the genius" to "Elon is a fraud and a liar".

I mean, I've thought he was a weird idiot since before it was cool, but I think the Twitter debacle really has made it a lot clearer to people (and has made me revise my previous assessment; I hadn't previously realised he was _this_ bad).

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#35

Even DARPA dropped the idea of brain surgery and has gone back to non-invasive technology, Neuralink should do the same. (2018) > "To try and figure out how to make this technology more accessible and not require surgical placement of a metal probe into people's brains, DARPA recently launched the NExt-Generation Nonsurgical Neurotechnology (N3) program. The plan is to make a device with similar capabilities, but it'…

I get really strong "Fringe" vibes from all of this

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#36

Too much hate here. It's surprising how quicly people jumped from "Elon is the genius" to "Elon is a fraud and a liar".

There is nothing surprising. Elon is for a very long time on the scene. You must be a really good performer not fail during 2 decade long show. I don’t mind Tesla’s poor self driving, Tesla Model X is really cool vehicle (with some design flaws, but it’s ok). My personal turning point was calling a diver “pedo”. After all he’s just another mega rich guy totally decoupled from reality.

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's pretty obvious that Waymo has done a million miles completely driverless with no major accidents, while Tesla has shipped a buggy and frequently updated piece of software to thousands of "beta testers" who demonstrate that it's unsafe on YouTube constantly.

Since when are frequent software updates a bad thing? At what point did any beta software worked perfectly?

This is troubling.. This was the point made above. I don't feel too comfortable with someone playing "POC" on my brain.

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#38
I really miss when discussions about Musk's companies were about the technology - there is a lot of interesting areas to discuss with Neurolink and how their approaching development. But now comment sections about anything Musk related are pointless - entirely about his personality and politics

Re: Musk’s bid to start Neuralink human trials denied by FDA in 2022, report says

#40

[flagged]

There are plenty of "neurotypical" people who apparently can't separate fact from fiction.

it is a personality disorder not Asperger, for example Trump has the same problem not due to Asperger but due to the personality disorder he has.
Post reply on HN