Live data from Hacker News

Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

d00k.net

31–40 of 81 posts

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#31
Spotify is mostly more of the same to me now. I get stuck in these ruts where I just listen to the same music because the interface makes that most convenient.

I’ve been on a good streak lately though with some new artists that make me go “why have I never heard these before”. But on the other hand I’m still mostly stuck in mono-genre land.

Also Spotify keeps pushing these “highlights” on me as if I don’t remember what I listened to this year.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#32
post #30

> I think a lot of people would probably look at my distaste of Spotify and recommend another, more suitable, streaming platform like Apple music or Pandora Just go to YTM? I stopped using Spotify when their client became slow and bloated. Then I went to GPM which was easy (didn't care for my library much). Then onto YTM (which in the beginning sucked), but is now close to parity with GPM. Took them a while but they…

Hate that navigating Spotify feels like loading websites. And it has felt that way ever since they moved their app to whatever pseudo-webapp framework it is that they’re using.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#33

I don't think I've ever been introduced to artists I wouldn't have listened to otherwise through Spotify. In general I find Spotify's recommendation to be slightly worse than just listening to the radio. I don't have a good alternative at the moment though. A long time ago I built a music recommendation system based on Discogs that made a vector space based on the genres and then found the most similar albums of one…

I gave up on Spotify a long time ago. Pandora more recently. I find myself just listening to a handful of channels on SiriusXM since the desktop streaming app came with my truck subscription.

Anything that I find myself liking a lot I head out to one of the very few record stores out here and buy it on vinyl. But then, I'm old and like having things in my hands and not just streamed. I buy paper books too.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#34
post #30

> I think a lot of people would probably look at my distaste of Spotify and recommend another, more suitable, streaming platform like Apple music or Pandora Just go to YTM? I stopped using Spotify when their client became slow and bloated. Then I went to GPM which was easy (didn't care for my library much). Then onto YTM (which in the beginning sucked), but is now close to parity with GPM. Took them a while but they…

Eh, I just left Youtube Music considering to go back to Spotify. Youtube Music has a terrible UI, lacks features, and feels like an afterthought to entice people to get Youtube Premium.

Honestly, if you're paying for Youtube Premium, you might as well use YT Music, but it's all around worse than Spotify.

I'm currently giving Deezer a try.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#35
Tidal is a relevant half measure for those looking to leave Spotify for a more album centric service with better profit sharing for artists. I used the FreeYourMusic app to migrate playlists, favorited songs, and albums.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#36

I genuinly want to stop giving Spotify my money because of the increasingly horrible user experience. But the sheer investment I have there in the form of more than ten year's worth of curated lists and folders makes it damn near impossible to leave without abandoning pretty much my entire "music library" which it has become at this point.

When I switched from Google music to Spotify (not entirely by choice), one of the things I really liked about Spotify was the folders. I like the idea of being able to make playlists in a folder and either listen to a specific list, or all at once. Unfortunately it seems like I can't listen to playlist folders in the mobile client, so that benefit quickly evaporated.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#37
post #19

I don't think I've ever been introduced to artists I wouldn't have listened to otherwise through Spotify. In general I find Spotify's recommendation to be slightly worse than just listening to the radio. I don't have a good alternative at the moment though. A long time ago I built a music recommendation system based on Discogs that made a vector space based on the genres and then found the most similar albums of one…

Everyone seems to hate YouTube recommendations but as someone who mostly use YouTube to listen to music their recommendations are amazing.

They used to be good, then Youtube has just stopped trying with me. It has shown me the same music recommendations for the past 2 years, and I'm not even joking.

The only thing that's always new and recommended is the latest hiphop song that's popular right now (i.e. video posted 12 hours ago, 3M views), and it should know I don't listen to hip hop, at all.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#38

I don't think I've ever been introduced to artists I wouldn't have listened to otherwise through Spotify. In general I find Spotify's recommendation to be slightly worse than just listening to the radio. I don't have a good alternative at the moment though. A long time ago I built a music recommendation system based on Discogs that made a vector space based on the genres and then found the most similar albums of one…

For me is the opposite, almost half the value i get from Spotify is about discovery (the other half is convenience). Specifically, I discovered amazing artists through the Discovery Weekly and the Artist's Radios. But also the "Fans also listen to" section in an artist profile. I found all sort of things, even obscure indies with a few thousands of listens and other "hidden gems". I'm really happy they now added the…

I really wish that I could (while respecting privacy) dig into real people's music tastes. I used to download songs with Napster and find some amazing song/artist, and them dig into what else that person had and loved almost all of it.

I have been looking to recreate this discovery through kindred-spirits-in-music ever since.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#39
post #4
post #2

This is very similar to what the British comedian James Acaster does/did. He buys music off Bandcamp then puts it on his iPod. He documented it all in his second book Perfect Sound Whatever, it helped him get over a breakup and depression around 2016 if I remember right. He jokes in his book that he has an 'iPod guy' who hooks him up with the old iPods. His recommendations here: https://www.jamesacaster.com/my-music/

Wow! What a list! I'd love to see more people make lists like it. I'll have to give the book a check too, thanks for sharing!

I try and make playlists for the year I've experienced on Apple Music: 2020: https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/the-year-is-2020/pl.u-RR... 2021: https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/the-year-is-2021/pl.u-vx...

This year I'm going to start writing out the songs.

Re: Leaving Spotify for freer pastures

#40
I still pay for Spotify premium cause I’m scared they would remove my username and replace it with a random gibberish string. My account is one of the first sign ups where you get to choose usernames. Bandcamp looks nice, I miss buying physical albums.
Post reply on HN