Live data from Hacker News

Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

the5to9.xyz

31–40 of 131 posts

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#31

Photopea should be GIMP's permanent embarrassment. I can't believe running a webapp offline written by a single person is more viable than a native program developed by a vast amount of contributors over decades.

Photopea's killer feature is the fact that it, for the most part, directly copies Photoshop's implementations of features. There's no learning curve because it's basically the same. On the other hand, GIMP still doesn't have Smart Objects or Adjustment Layers.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#32

Photopea should be GIMP's permanent embarrassment. I can't believe running a webapp offline written by a single person is more viable than a native program developed by a vast amount of contributors over decades.

Photopea's killer feature is the fact that it, for the most part, directly copies Photoshop's implementations of features. There's no learning curve because it's basically the same. On the other hand, GIMP still doesn't have Smart Objects or Adjustment Layers.

No adjustment layers? That is like photoshop 101. That's pretty embarrassing for GIMP.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#33

> But it has a few problems. It takes up a ton of computing power and battery, which makes it difficult to use on old/slow computers. And the biggest thing, cost. Given it's a Javascript program I'm not sure how Photopea solves those problems with Adobe Photoshop other than cost.

it could do what figma does, use web assembly and web workers

WebAssembly only helps to a small degree here. SIMD support is still too limited and real multithreading will probably never be possible due to spectre vulnerability, so you are leaving about two orders of magnitude of performance on the table.

WebGL 2.0 could be a band aid fix, but it is quite limited compared to CUDA. I'd also expect a bunch of compatibility issues.

As a side note, Photopea already uses WebAssembly.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#34
post #24

Photopea should be GIMP's permanent embarrassment. I can't believe running a webapp offline written by a single person is more viable than a native program developed by a vast amount of contributors over decades.

Ditto Affinity Photo. Even paid programs are abysmal compared to Photopea.

Really? I heard Affinity Photo was great, though I haven't really used it.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#36

Photopea should be GIMP's permanent embarrassment. I can't believe running a webapp offline written by a single person is more viable than a native program developed by a vast amount of contributors over decades.

Photopea's killer feature is the fact that it, for the most part, directly copies Photoshop's implementations of features. There's no learning curve because it's basically the same. On the other hand, GIMP still doesn't have Smart Objects or Adjustment Layers.

Once upon a time there was a fork called 'gimpshop' that added a PS-like UI to gimp. Clever idea. Warning - the current gimpshop domain hosts some scammer's adware-laden rip-off.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#37

> Including his own PDF parser, content-aware fill feature, and even supporting GIFs. Wow, even GIF! Quick history lesson: 1987: GIF invented (Wilhite) 2010: Content aware fill invented (Barnes)

I always wonder how so many programs get away with content aware fill with all the patents.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#38
post #29

I recently switched back to using Ubuntu as my desktop OS, and was intrigued to see that Photopea was the default app to open many file types, including PDF. I thought that was odd because while Photopea is free-of-charge, it's not completely open source [1]. [1] https://github.com/photopea/photopea

[deleted]

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#39

Photopea should be GIMP's permanent embarrassment. I can't believe running a webapp offline written by a single person is more viable than a native program developed by a vast amount of contributors over decades.

Krita on the other hand is really great and getting better every day.

I'm all in on Krita and believe it will be the next Blender.

Re: Photopea: A free Photoshop alternative making millions

#40
post #29

I recently switched back to using Ubuntu as my desktop OS, and was intrigued to see that Photopea was the default app to open many file types, including PDF. I thought that was odd because while Photopea is free-of-charge, it's not completely open source [1]. [1] https://github.com/photopea/photopea

That’s interesting, I haven’t experienced this. Evince should be the default PDF reader, I can’t imagine why it would be Photopea.
Post reply on HN