Live data from Hacker News

Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

github.blog

31–40 of 70 posts

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#31

Just in time for Netlify to discontinue support for private GitHub repositories for free plans. Good thing cloudflare still has free Cloudflare pages support for private GitHub pages.

Do you have a link to where they've said that, that really sucks, I've had a much smoother experience setting up pages with Netlify than Cloudflare.

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have projects lovingly maintained for a decade (and responding to genuine issues with bug fixes within days) that have under five stars. Not a good metric.

I still strongly suspect that you have more stars than any "competitive" OSS projects in the niche (if any even exist), which is all I'm using the stars as a heuristic for (initial sort).

> if any even exist

Fair point.

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They may become mandatory signals used for finding jobs? Thin line of thought maybe, but I honestly don’t mind the features I’m just trying to give a talking point to rally around.

It's infuriating that people don't make themselves easily reachable on GitHub. So many people with so much talent, wasting it on some really meaningless stuff.

What's "meaningless stuff" to you in this context?

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#35
post #2

Maybe I'm deviating from the general consensus here, but to me the social-network-isms in GitHub are an anti-pattern in business and undesired in such a highly useful utility service.

Do you have an actual complaint here, or just buzzwords? Calling something an “anti-pattern” or “undesired” doesn’t mean anything. Your comment contains no substance that couldn’t have been conveyed by saying “I hate it”. If you don’t like it, don’t use it. That’s what I do. Is there an actual reason that the mere existence of social networking features is harmful to those of us who choose not to bother with them?

Widespread practices infect norms.

For example, thanks to the norms fostered on GitHub, you can no longer expect the average programmer to file good bug reports or to just interact in an appropriate way with the bugtracker.

We can't really talk about "wikis", either, without confusion about what a wiki even is—again, thanks to GitHub.

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#36
post #2

Maybe I'm deviating from the general consensus here, but to me the social-network-isms in GitHub are an anti-pattern in business and undesired in such a highly useful utility service.

What differentiates Github from any other git provider, except for the social network-isms?

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#37
post #2

Maybe I'm deviating from the general consensus here, but to me the social-network-isms in GitHub are an anti-pattern in business and undesired in such a highly useful utility service.

Aren't private profiles in the opposite direction of social network-isms?

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the future children will argue over who inherits their parent's Hacker News karma. To avoid legal complications be sure to specify in your will which favorite child inherits your Hacker News legacy.

Will there be an inheritance tax on HN karma?

Absolutely. There should also be a wealth tax system that automatically reduces your karma by 1% every month, and distributes that amount equally to other commenters.

Re: Private profiles are now generally available on GitHub

#40

Just in time for Netlify to discontinue support for private GitHub repositories for free plans. Good thing cloudflare still has free Cloudflare pages support for private GitHub pages.

Do you have a link to where they've said that, that really sucks, I've had a much smoother experience setting up pages with Netlify than Cloudflare.

I scanned the last couple months of their blog posts and could not find anything to support that claim. The docs or pricing page don’t seem to indicate anything like that either.

The only related thing I found was that free accounts are limited to one user that can trigger deploys in private repos, while anyone can trigger deploys in public repos (assuming I understood the announcement correctly).

Post reply on HN