Live data from Hacker News

Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

english.tau.ac.il

31–40 of 263 posts

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#32
post #24
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

Depends on the church in question. I know gay people who are accepted by their congregation, and churches that don't have issues with gay people at all. The biggest LGBT youth group in my city is organized by and hosted in a Christian church.

[deleted]

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#33
post #21
post #13

I'd like to see similar study about the original gateway drug: "24-hour News Channels", which was followed by "24-hour Outrage-News Channels". Seems like we've been building toward this, the interactivity of the internet was the paradigm shift (to use a 90's term). EDIT: I realize it isn't news messing with youths' self-esteem (well, in some cases it is), but it is related in that the media is custom-made to drive en…

Engagement with broadcast TV vs with hyper-personalized apps is a specious comparison.

TiVo monetized hyper-personalized broadcast TV, by interposing ads based on all sorts of calculated data, into recorded broadcast TV streams, though.

So it's more continuous a transition i suspect than people consider.

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#34
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most in-person social activity is good for your mental health. Studies show this includes church: https://www.npr.org/2019/11/05/776270553/hidden-brain-does-g... Facebook is singled out because they are the largest practitioner of surveillance capitalism. The entire idea of “optimizing for engagement,” where Facebook has been a pioneer and the largest player, is increasingly being shown to be a primary driver of poli…

Quoted post unavailable.

The Unitarian church ordained their first gay minister in 1979 and conducted its first same sex marriage ceremony in 1984: https://www.hrc.org/resources/stances-of-faiths-on-lgbt-issu...

Not that I'm advocating for UUA, I'm atheist myself, but from what I've heard it sounds like a hippie commune focused around the bible.

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#35
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most in-person social activity is good for your mental health. Studies show this includes church: https://www.npr.org/2019/11/05/776270553/hidden-brain-does-g... Facebook is singled out because they are the largest practitioner of surveillance capitalism. The entire idea of “optimizing for engagement,” where Facebook has been a pioneer and the largest player, is increasingly being shown to be a primary driver of poli…

Quoted post unavailable.

Well said.

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#36
Consider your attention.

You pay attention. Concentrate your attention. Occasionally have your attention jerked around by distractions.

Consider what you do when you think, read, watch tv, consume facebook. Consider what you are doing with your attention. That shape.

If you do it a lot then that shape intensifies.

And that shape sticks. It becomes your normal.

And the shape of your attention dictates your reality.

It's important to take that into account.

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#37
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Engagement with broadcast TV vs with hyper-personalized apps is a specious comparison.

Do you care to elaborate? Why do you say it's specious?

Well engagement implies a certain amount to decision making and real-time action. TV watching is pretty much passive, and I just have a hard time believing the brain is impacted similarly but such different types of activity.

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#38

IDK... I know Facebook feeds are different for each person but for me there are basically zero posts from people I know on Facebook anymore, it's just ads and videos of random TikTok style videos.

Did you know you can look at profiles, not just the feed?

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#39

Anecdotally, Facebook seems relatively tame these days compared to the firehose of doom & gloom, violent videos, outrage porn, and outright misinformation that fills Reddit and Twitter. Browsing Reddit’s default feeds or popular posts is a wild experience these days.

Twitter is poison

Re: Facebook proven to negatively impact mental health

#40

I don’t get why Facebook is so often singled out in these types of studies. What about other activities like dating or school or going to church? I bet those can be shown to increase anxiety and be bad for mental health

Most in-person social activity is good for your mental health. Studies show this includes church: https://www.npr.org/2019/11/05/776270553/hidden-brain-does-g... Facebook is singled out because they are the largest practitioner of surveillance capitalism. The entire idea of “optimizing for engagement,” where Facebook has been a pioneer and the largest player, is increasingly being shown to be a primary driver of poli…

It never occurred to me before, but the Roman Catholic Church, with confession[0], is surely the largest historical "surveillance capitalism" out there. I wonder if Facebook has hockey-sticked them yet.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confession_(religion)#Catholic...

Post reply on HN