Live data from Hacker News

Taking action against scraping for hire

about.fb.com

31–40 of 240 posts

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#31

Of course, Facebook wants to make it sound like scraping is illegal, when it generally isn't. But account hijacking and mass-creation of accounts just to access private pages are clear violations of the Facebook and Instagram ToS, so they surely can sue for that.

Since when do you get sued for breaching TOS?

Since when do you get sued for breaching a contract? When the offense is worth it.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#35
post #30

HN is hypocritical - most commenters here are against this because "Meta bad," but at the same time, most commenters wouldn't want their posts shared privately amongst friends to be scraped and made available publicly.

For that to happen, one of your friends would have had to willingly allow this tool to scrape their social network, which would include your private posts.

Is the scraper to blame here, or the friend?

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#36

Of course, Facebook wants to make it sound like scraping is illegal, when it generally isn't. But account hijacking and mass-creation of accounts just to access private pages are clear violations of the Facebook and Instagram ToS, so they surely can sue for that.

Since when do you get sued for breaching TOS?

Since you start a business on the violation.

"Since when do I get sued for taking too many free samples from Costco?" -> "Since you started taking millions of them to resell"

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#37
post #30

HN is hypocritical - most commenters here are against this because "Meta bad," but at the same time, most commenters wouldn't want their posts shared privately amongst friends to be scraped and made available publicly.

lol maybe if you don't want that happening you shouldn't be using Facebook

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#38
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's their platform. Do you really want some random companies scraping your facebook and instagram posts?

Yes. I want a free and open web.

Good for you. Normal people do not want posts shared privately amongst friends to become publicly available.

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#39
post #14
post #3

Data harvesting is moral for me, but not for thee.

It's their platform. Do you really want some random companies scraping your facebook and instagram posts?

> Do you really want some random companies scraping your facebook and instagram posts?

Thought experiment: if you want to keep control over your data, try something radical: don't hand it to Meta/FB/IG at all

(Full disclosure, I'm neither on FB nor IG)

Re: Taking action against scraping for hire

#40
post #29

Of course, Facebook wants to make it sound like scraping is illegal, when it generally isn't. But account hijacking and mass-creation of accounts just to access private pages are clear violations of the Facebook and Instagram ToS, so they surely can sue for that.

Violation of ToS does not mean a violation of the law.

I don't think I know the answer, but I'm curious:

Does violating a website's TOS meant your accessing it beyond your authority, making it a violation of the US's Computer Fraud and Abuse Act?

Post reply on HN